Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
Moderators: BillShankly, John Cena, swannsong, Forum Admins
Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
We had a player sent off on the weekend after receiving a 2nd yellow card....I just received an email regarding his suspension...I may be wrong but last year the precedent was that only straight red cards for violent conduct etc attracted a suspension in pre-season friendlies....has this changed and how were clubs informed ?

Southern Knights SC - 2024 - Celebrating 30 Years of SAASL Football
SAASL facebook : Southern Knights SC facebook
swannsong Facebook : Elizabeth Downs SC facebook
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
Based on the FFSA Rules & Regulations
(7) A player who receives a mandatory suspension in a Friendly, must serve that suspension in the next
Friendly. A player who receives a match suspension in addition to a mandatory match suspension for
an offence that occurs in a Friendly may be requested by the Disciplinary Committee to serve the
suspension in the next official match(es) in which his or her club participates rather than the next
Friendly.
Swanny, i think the carton of beer he owes for a send off is a better punishment...
(7) A player who receives a mandatory suspension in a Friendly, must serve that suspension in the next
Friendly. A player who receives a match suspension in addition to a mandatory match suspension for
an offence that occurs in a Friendly may be requested by the Disciplinary Committee to serve the
suspension in the next official match(es) in which his or her club participates rather than the next
Friendly.
Swanny, i think the carton of beer he owes for a send off is a better punishment...
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
Not worth playing friendlies if you lose players for league games.. 2 yellows in a friendly and you cop this carry over to a league Round....



Southern Knights SC - 2024 - Celebrating 30 Years of SAASL Football
SAASL facebook : Southern Knights SC facebook
swannsong Facebook : Elizabeth Downs SC facebook
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
Are you suggesting that ill discipline goes unpunished?
Maybe take the responsibility that this player did something wrong and deal with it?
Irrespective of when it happened, it has happened - agreed the process could have been better publicized but “do the crime do the time”
Only in my experience but refs generally tend to avoid dishing out cards if they can in pre season - if that were the case then it must have been pretty bad to get two?
Only playing devils advocate and asking the questions....
Maybe take the responsibility that this player did something wrong and deal with it?
Irrespective of when it happened, it has happened - agreed the process could have been better publicized but “do the crime do the time”
Only in my experience but refs generally tend to avoid dishing out cards if they can in pre season - if that were the case then it must have been pretty bad to get two?
Only playing devils advocate and asking the questions....
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
Not suggesting 'going unpunished' ... just the precedent changing without notification ... our players received their fair share of over exuberant tackles that went uncarded without too much fuss ... was two yellow cards for two solid tackles and he left the ground without a fuss.Fact Hunt wrote:Are you suggesting that ill discipline goes unpunished?
Maybe take the responsibility that this player did something wrong and deal with it?
Irrespective of when it happened, it has happened - agreed the process could have been better publicized but “do the crime do the time”
Only in my experience but refs generally tend to avoid dishing out cards if they can in pre season - if that were the case then it must have been pretty bad to get two?
Only playing devils advocate and asking the questions....
Hurts more when you cover the referees fees for As & Bs (in this case out of my own pockets) and the opposition don't offer any share of the fees and leave a mess behind for several of our spectators to pick up....

Southern Knights SC - 2024 - Celebrating 30 Years of SAASL Football
SAASL facebook : Southern Knights SC facebook
swannsong Facebook : Elizabeth Downs SC facebook
-
- Apprentice
- Posts: 139
- Joined: Sun Feb 10, 2013 10:35 pm
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
Maybe the referees have missed that memo cause the refs we have had have been handing them out like Christmas cards and for minor stuff as well.Fact Hunt wrote:Are you suggesting that ill discipline goes unpunished?
Maybe take the responsibility that this player did something wrong and deal with it?
Irrespective of when it happened, it has happened - agreed the process could have been better publicized but “do the crime do the time”
Only in my experience but refs generally tend to avoid dishing out cards if they can in pre season - if that were the case then it must have been pretty bad to get two?
Only playing devils advocate and asking the questions....
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
Agreed. Maybe teach him how to tackle. You get sent off, you get suspended. Deal with it.Fact Hunt wrote:Are you suggesting that ill discipline goes unpunished?
Maybe take the responsibility that this player did something wrong and deal with it?
Irrespective of when it happened, it has happened - agreed the process could have been better publicized but “do the crime do the time”
Only in my experience but refs generally tend to avoid dishing out cards if they can in pre season - if that were the case then it must have been pretty bad to get two?
Only playing devils advocate and asking the questions....
- Bomber
- Vice Chairman
- Posts: 60561
- Joined: Tue Apr 04, 2006 11:40 am
- Has thanked: 46 times
- Been thanked: 141 times
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
I wouldn't invite them for a friendly next season, that's for sure.swannsong wrote:Not suggesting 'going unpunished' ... just the precedent changing without notification ... our players received their fair share of over exuberant tackles that went uncarded without too much fuss ... was two yellow cards for two solid tackles and he left the ground without a fuss.Fact Hunt wrote:Are you suggesting that ill discipline goes unpunished?
Maybe take the responsibility that this player did something wrong and deal with it?
Irrespective of when it happened, it has happened - agreed the process could have been better publicized but “do the crime do the time”
Only in my experience but refs generally tend to avoid dishing out cards if they can in pre season - if that were the case then it must have been pretty bad to get two?
Only playing devils advocate and asking the questions....
Hurts more when you cover the referees fees for As & Bs (in this case out of my own pockets) and the opposition don't offer any share of the fees and leave a mess behind for several of our spectators to pick up....
Ignore this signature
-
- Star Player
- Posts: 2850
- Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2012 8:40 am
- Has thanked: 8 times
- Been thanked: 3 times
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
Didn't you read up on the implications of affiliation?swannsong wrote:Not suggesting 'going unpunished' ... just the precedent changing without notification ... our players received their fair share of over exuberant tackles that went uncarded without too much fuss ... was two yellow cards for two solid tackles and he left the ground without a fuss.Fact Hunt wrote:Are you suggesting that ill discipline goes unpunished?
Maybe take the responsibility that this player did something wrong and deal with it?
Irrespective of when it happened, it has happened - agreed the process could have been better publicized but “do the crime do the time”
Only in my experience but refs generally tend to avoid dishing out cards if they can in pre season - if that were the case then it must have been pretty bad to get two?
Only playing devils advocate and asking the questions....
Hurts more when you cover the referees fees for As & Bs (in this case out of my own pockets) and the opposition don't offer any share of the fees and leave a mess behind for several of our spectators to pick up....
It's all in the Delivery!
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
I fully understand, personally I never received a single card in my voluntary playing 'career' from 1968 to 2017..Nugget wrote:Agreed. Maybe teach him how to tackle. You get sent off, you get suspended. Deal with it.Fact Hunt wrote:Are you suggesting that ill discipline goes unpunished?
Maybe take the responsibility that this player did something wrong and deal with it?
Irrespective of when it happened, it has happened - agreed the process could have been better publicized but “do the crime do the time”
Only in my experience but refs generally tend to avoid dishing out cards if they can in pre season - if that were the case then it must have been pretty bad to get two?
Only playing devils advocate and asking the questions....
They were decent tackles


Southern Knights SC - 2024 - Celebrating 30 Years of SAASL Football
SAASL facebook : Southern Knights SC facebook
swannsong Facebook : Elizabeth Downs SC facebook
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
Particularly the section on smarmy comments from the naysayersBrian the Postman wrote:Didn't you read up on the implications of affiliation?swannsong wrote:Not suggesting 'going unpunished' ... just the precedent changing without notification ... our players received their fair share of over exuberant tackles that went uncarded without too much fuss ... was two yellow cards for two solid tackles and he left the ground without a fuss.Fact Hunt wrote:Are you suggesting that ill discipline goes unpunished?
Maybe take the responsibility that this player did something wrong and deal with it?
Irrespective of when it happened, it has happened - agreed the process could have been better publicized but “do the crime do the time”
Only in my experience but refs generally tend to avoid dishing out cards if they can in pre season - if that were the case then it must have been pretty bad to get two?
Only playing devils advocate and asking the questions....
Hurts more when you cover the referees fees for As & Bs (in this case out of my own pockets) and the opposition don't offer any share of the fees and leave a mess behind for several of our spectators to pick up....


Southern Knights SC - 2024 - Celebrating 30 Years of SAASL Football
SAASL facebook : Southern Knights SC facebook
swannsong Facebook : Elizabeth Downs SC facebook
-
- Ball Boy
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Tue Mar 13, 2018 7:16 pm
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
Aint there reservses playing there again ?
Bomber wrote:I wouldn't invite them for a friendly next season, that's for sure.swannsong wrote:Not suggesting 'going unpunished' ... just the precedent changing without notification ... our players received their fair share of over exuberant tackles that went uncarded without too much fuss ... was two yellow cards for two solid tackles and he left the ground without a fuss.Fact Hunt wrote:Are you suggesting that ill discipline goes unpunished?
Maybe take the responsibility that this player did something wrong and deal with it?
Irrespective of when it happened, it has happened - agreed the process could have been better publicized but “do the crime do the time”
Only in my experience but refs generally tend to avoid dishing out cards if they can in pre season - if that were the case then it must have been pretty bad to get two?
Only playing devils advocate and asking the questions....
Hurts more when you cover the referees fees for As & Bs (in this case out of my own pockets) and the opposition don't offer any share of the fees and leave a mess behind for several of our spectators to pick up....
-
- Ball Boy
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Tue Mar 13, 2018 7:16 pm
Re: Pre Season Friendlies - Cards
Cry Me A River comes to mind very quicklyswannsong wrote:Not suggesting 'going unpunished' ... just the precedent changing without notification ... our players received their fair share of over exuberant tackles that went uncarded without too much fuss ... was two yellow cards for two solid tackles and he left the ground without a fuss.Fact Hunt wrote:Are you suggesting that ill discipline goes unpunished?
Maybe take the responsibility that this player did something wrong and deal with it?
Irrespective of when it happened, it has happened - agreed the process could have been better publicized but “do the crime do the time”
Only in my experience but refs generally tend to avoid dishing out cards if they can in pre season - if that were the case then it must have been pretty bad to get two?
Only playing devils advocate and asking the questions....
Hurts more when you cover the referees fees for As & Bs (in this case out of my own pockets) and the opposition don't offer any share of the fees and leave a mess behind for several of our spectators to pick up....