Worst Penalty Ever

[Juventus FC]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-psa7Utw4JM

[Bomber]

Two questions - why the yellow card and secondly, the keeper moved off his line before the kick was taken, so should it have been re-taken?

[Blue Mastiff]

yellow card was for being such a twat!

i was more concerned with the fact 2 players wanted to give him a hair massage after the penalty was taken

[Juventus FC]

Two questions - why the yellow card and secondly, the keeper moved off his line before the kick was taken, so should it have been re-taken?

Ill see if I can track down the referee's phone number for you

[Juventino]

Yellow card for his stop-start run, which is not allowed.

[Outlaw 2.0]

Yellow card for his stop-start run, which is not allowed.

but not a bookable offence surely, the game should have been play on as the keeper had the ball.

[Mato]

hahaha

love the yellow card, serves the fool right

[Redmum's Avatar]

Yellow card for his stop-start run, which is not allowed.

but not a bookable offence surely, the game should have been play on as the keeper had the ball.

Should have been retaken as the keeper moved off his line before the ball was kicked.

[Der_Tiser]

Two questions - why the yellow card and secondly, the keeper moved off his line before the kick was taken, so should it have been re-taken?

the yellow card is for stopping his run, you can't do that anymore, it is a bookable offence
so it is irrelevant that the keeper is off his line because an infringement occurred before the ball was even back in play

[Redmum's Avatar]

Two questions - why the yellow card and secondly, the keeper moved off his line before the kick was taken, so should it have been re-taken?

the yellow card is for stopping his run, you can't do that anymore, it is a bookable offence
so it is irrelevant that the keeper is off his line because an infringement occurred before the ball was even back in play

In which case the ball is dead so the referee can't restart play without anything except to retake the penalty.

[Der_Tiser]

Two questions - why the yellow card and secondly, the keeper moved off his line before the kick was taken, so should it have been re-taken?

the yellow card is for stopping his run, you can't do that anymore, it is a bookable offence
so it is irrelevant that the keeper is off his line because an infringement occurred before the ball was even back in play

In which case the ball is dead so the referee can't restart play without anything except to retake the penalty.

not under FIFA's new rules

[God is an Englishman]

No, the kick should not have been retaken. Had he scored then yes, it would have retaken. He is booked for the deception on the keeper.

It is only an offence if the keeper is deceived. It's like the call of "MY BALL", most people think that's an offence as well, but it's only an offence if someone is deceived.

[Bomber]

The keeper moving off his line before the player took the kick, to me, occurred first, therefore it precedes that the keeper erred first, the kick should be retaken. Had the keeper been on the line as he should be before the ball is touched, then I'd agree with you.

[BADA BING]

[Der_Tiser]

a yellow card offence is more serious than a keeper moving off his line, hence that overrides
say you take a dive and someone stomps on you for it... who gets the free kick?

[Bomber]

a yellow card offence is more serious than a keeper moving off his line, hence that overrides
say you take a dive and someone stomps on you for it... who gets the free kick?

If the ref blew play up for the dive, the opposing team. He can then send the stomper off.

[God is an Englishman]

a yellow card offence is more serious than a keeper moving off his line, hence that overrides
say you take a dive and someone stomps on you for it... who gets the free kick?

The other team would get the free kick but they'd be down to 10 men.

[God is an Englishman]

The keeper moving off his line before the player took the kick, to me, occurred first, therefore it precedes that the keeper erred first, the kick should be retaken. Had the keeper been on the line as he should be before the ball is touched, then I'd agree with you.

what came first the chicken or the egg?

Did he move because of the fake or because of the fake?

[swannsong]

This is amoving argument and there's not a lot on the line !

[Loretta Jones]

The keeper moving off his line before the player took the kick, to me, occurred first, therefore it precedes that the keeper erred first, the kick should be retaken. Had the keeper been on the line as he should be before the ball is touched, then I'd agree with you.

what came first the chicken or the egg?
Did he move because of the fake or because of the fake?

He was off his line before the fake so you can't claim that it caused him to be off his line.

[Der_Tiser]

a yellow card offence is more serious than a keeper moving off his line, hence that overrides
say you take a dive and someone stomps on you for it... who gets the free kick?

If the ref blew play up for the dive, the opposing team. He can then send the stomper off.

but what if the stoper's team plays advantage from the dive?

[Bomber]

The keeper moving off his line before the player took the kick, to me, occurred first, therefore it precedes that the keeper erred first, the kick should be retaken. Had the keeper been on the line as he should be before the ball is touched, then I'd agree with you.

what came first the chicken or the egg?

Did he move because of the fake or because of the fake?

Because of the fake? End of, he moved off his line before the ball was touched. Shouldn't matter...SURELY....... as per LOFG!

[Der_Tiser]

The keeper moving off his line before the player took the kick, to me, occurred first, therefore it precedes that the keeper erred first, the kick should be retaken. Had the keeper been on the line as he should be before the ball is touched, then I'd agree with you.

what came first the chicken or the egg?

Did he move because of the fake or because of the fake?

Because of the fake? End of, he moved off his line before the ball was touched. Shouldn't matter...SURELY....... as per LOFG!

LOFG?

[Bomber]

LOTG (typo)

[God is an Englishman]

charlie adam

[bapa]

charlie adam

[totsreds08]

charlie adam

Why are you laughing Rooney?

[Stonthialo]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zXvGgb-P_7Y

[Bomber]

charlie adam

Row Z effort that one, but Chucky still gets to drink from the trophy.

[bapa]

charlie adam

Row Z effort that one, but Chucky still gets to drink from the trophy.

great, what a way to tarnish it...