You are the ref!

[God is an Englishman]

Attacker has a shot and the defender on the line catches the ball, stopping a certain goal. However, before you can blow the whistle, he drops the ball and it rolls over the goal line and into the net.

As the ref: What do you do?

A special prize of me saying WELL DONE to the person with the correct answer.

[God is an Englishman]

Rob Lozza - WELL DONE! (via PM)

[God is an Englishman]

Wraith - WRONG
Fantasista - WRONG

[Randoman]

It depends, if its womans football then handball doesnt count so it's simply just a goal.

[Bomber]

Attacker has a shot and the defender on the line catches the ball, stopping a certain goal. However, before you can blow the whistle, he drops the ball and it rolls over the goal line and into the net.

As the ref: What do you do?

A special prize of me saying WELL DONE to the person with the correct answer.

Blow the whistle.

[mvsc]

where is my well done?

[Wraith]

Where is my well done?

[Bomber]

Wraith - WRONG
Fantasista - WRONG

[Randoman]

lol!

[ontheblackburner]

is it a red card and a penalty because the ball stopped when they caught it?

[ssnapoli]

As a referee you give the as the goal is scored and caution the play for is guilty of unsporting behaviour.

[Wraith]

Wraith - WRONG
Fantasista - WRONG

correct.

He never said no well done if you get it on second attempt.

[ssnapoli]

it no't a red card the is goal is scored.

[legga]

If its maiwank you beat the shit out of everyone around and hide like rabbits.. I would pay the goal..

[Chico]

As a referee you give the as the goal is scored and caution the play for is guilty of unsporting behaviour.

WELL DONE... correct answer...

[Randoman]

what is wrong with your typing ssnapoli!

But yes, that was my answer too, though in English...

[Wraith]

If its maiwank you beat the cabernet out of everyone around and hide like rabbits.. I would pay the goal..

[Cooper]

Penalty and Red Card

We had this same situation the other week one of our guys stopped a certain goal on the goal line with his hand ball dropped and rolled in. Ref had blown the whistle quickly and awarded a penalty (which we saved ) Our player was straight red carded and sent off.

[bapa]

fark that!


Smack the player over the head, who caught the ball
blow for fulltime citing that the game is getting out of control
head to the bar and buy ur mates a round of beers!

[KING NUGGETT]

Penalty and Red Card

We had this same situation the other week one of our guys stopped a certain goal on the goal line with his hand ball dropped and rolled in. Ref had blown the whistle quickly and awarded a penalty (which we saved ) Our player was straight red carded and sent off.

Correct Decission

[God is an Englishman]

Penalty and Red Card

We had this same situation the other week one of our guys stopped a certain goal on the goal line with his hand ball dropped and rolled in. Ref had blown the whistle quickly and awarded a penalty (which we saved ) Our player was straight red carded and sent off.

different scenario to what you have said.

[God is an Englishman]

King Nuggett - WRONG
Randoman - WELL DONE

[God is an Englishman]

As a referee you give the as the goal is scored and caution the play for is guilty of unsporting behaviour.

WELL DONE... correct answer...

thank you to chico for doing my job for me!

[Outlaw 2.0]

Surely the game could not have played on to advantage because it is a red card offense and as a result the game stops at the incident (in this case being the handball) not when the whistle is blown. As a result of that no goal can be awarded regardless of when the whistle is blown. The Referee would have to award a penalty for deliberate handball and a red card the player for the same reason.

however I'm going to agree with Randoman purely to get a Well Done. . . .

[God is an Englishman]

OK! This is the answer.

Because the ball has crossed the line before you have blown for the handball, you have effectively played advantage. Would you consider it fair to pull back a goal, in order to give the attacking team a chance of a goal. NO, of course not. So you allow the goal.

Now for the punishment, is it a red or a yellow. The punishment for a deliberate handball is a yellow card unless you have Denied an Obvious Goal Scoring Opportunity, well he hasn't denied that goal scoring opportunity because the ball is in the net and you've given the goal. So, it's only a yellow.

[Randoman]

Surely the game could not have played on to advantage because it is a red card offense and as a result the game stops at the incident (in this case being the handball) not when the whistle is blown. As a result of that no goal can be awarded regardless of when the whistle is blown. The Referee would have to award a penalty for deliberate handball and a red card the player for the same reason.

however I'm going to agree with Randoman purely to get a Well Done. . . .

Game doesnt stop at the incident, its stops when the whistle is blown!

[blackout]

The most amazing thing about all this is that GIAE reads the Guardian. Who would have thought it.

Unless You are the Ref! is syndicated in the Sun too?

[penalty]

Denying a goal or an obvious goalscoring opportunity
There are two sending-off offences that deal with denying an opponent an
obvious opportunity to score a goal. It is not necessary for the offence to occur
inside the penalty area.
If the referee applies advantage during an obvious goalscoring opportunity and
a goal is scored directly, despite the opponent’s handling the ball or fouling an
opponent, the player cannot be sent off but he may still be cautioned.
Referees should consider the following circumstances when deciding whether
to send off a player for denying a goal or an obvious goalscoring opportunity:
• the distance between the offence and the goal
• the likelihood of keeping or gaining control of the ball
• the direction of the play
• the location and number of defenders
• the offence which denies an opponent an obvious goalscoring opportunity
may be an offence that incurs a direct free kick or an indirect free kick

[colon clenser]

taking it a step further ie,,,the harry kewell red card in the world cup,,i believe the attacking team should have the option of the goal and the player not sent off,,,or having the penalty and the red car

[kramerica]

OK! This is the answer.

Because the ball has crossed the line before you have blown for the handball, you have effectively played advantage. Would you consider it fair to pull back a goal, in order to give the attacking team a chance of a goal. NO, of course not. So you allow the goal.

Now for the punishment, is it a red or a yellow. The punishment for a deliberate handball is a yellow card unless you have Denied an Obvious Goal Scoring Opportunity, well he hasn't denied that goal scoring opportunity because the ball is in the net and you've given the goal. So, it's only a yellow.

Firstly I would like to qualify, I am in Launceston Tasmania & have already had 5 pints of James Boag XXX ALE (nice drop).

I would have to disagree and would challenge anyone that has agreed with you or given you an answer similar to this scenario.

If the ball hit the players hand and went in, then yes I agree with your statement.

But if the defender/player has caught the ball, then that is a completley different circumstance. In my opinion I would blow the whistle (I would imagine you where in the motion of doing so) and two things:

1) It would have to be a Penalty (the opportunity for the striker to actually score once again).

2) Player denied an obivious goal scoring opportunity. Couldn't care less that he throws the ball into the net, that is technically an own goal and if I was the striker that hit that ball, I would not be happy with that. As a referee you would have to give it a TOG, by the book.

Only my opinion. If the same player came into the box with a two footed, studs up challenge and nicked the striker.......and the ball still went into the net for a goal. Sorry I would send off that player, yes advantage (more so than in the case you state, in my opinion) but the intent was still there and yes goal would stand.

Have I had to many pints?