MVP AWARD

[KING NUGGETT]

Last few years it has been talked about having a Most Valuable Player Award voted by the opposition Captain's & Coach's after each game.

I think it would be a fantastic award to be voted by your peers rather than the Referee's .

What's everyone's thoughts on this???

[lisbon lion]

Last few years it has been talked about having a Most Valuable Player Award voted by the opposition Captain's & Coach's after each game.

I think it would be a fantastic award to be voted by your peers rather than the Referee's .

What's everyone's thoughts on this???

3 votes for you macnuggets the forum guru.....seriously though would be much more meaningfull to the recipient as we all know referees are little heroes who were s_H_I_T PLAYERS

[KING NUGGETT]

would be much more meaningfull to the recipient as we all know referees are little heroes who were s_H_I_T PLAYERS

And they have there favourites, isn't that right Bert

[mvsc]

it's hard to give a player's player of the year award when you only see players from other clubs twice in one year

[lisbon lion]

would be much more meaningfull to the recipient as we all know referees are little heroes who were s_H_I_T PLAYERS

And they have there favourites, isn't that right Bert

bit harsh man

[Pommy09]

it's hard to give a player's player of the year award when you only see players from other clubs twice in one year

he means instead of the refs doing it each game. the coaches give 3-2-1 to players of the opposite team that they play each week

[KING NUGGETT]

it's hard to give a player's player of the year award when you only see players from other clubs twice in one year

he means instead of the refs doing it each game. the coaches give 3-2-1 to players of the opposite team that they play each week

Correct, the Opposition Captain & Coach !!!

[Pommy09]

it's hard to give a player's player of the year award when you only see players from other clubs twice in one year

he means instead of the refs doing it each game. the coaches give 3-2-1 to players of the opposite team that they play each week

Correct, the Opposition Captain & Coach !!!

i agree with you on that nugget. as a ref in the federation. its hard to give 3-2-1 after the game cause you dont really pay attention to who plays well but more keeping the game in control

[mvsc]

oh, so change the current structure as opposed to creating a new award?

[Pommy09]

yea thats what nuggets ment

[Outlaw 2.0]

The reason that this wouldn't work is that for example Elizabeth Downs play Parafield Gardens the last day of the year and Nathan Day has a blinder however if he were to get 3 votes he would leap frog Paul Ebomo for the players player award an win it so Parafield Gardens decide to give the 3 votes to Scott Morrison instead who isn't going to win. This ensures that Paul cannot be leapfrogged and has the best chance of winning the award.

When a ref does it it's an un-biased view on who they thought played the game in the best spirits and contributed most. This enables us to have a result which cannot be tampered with.






***PLEASE NOTE I USED THOSE TWO CLUBS PURELY AS AN EXAMPLE AND IN NO WAY THINK THAT EITHER PARAFIELD GARDENS OR ELIZABETH DOWNS WOULD DO SUCH A THING TO WIN AN AWARD***

[lisbon lion]

disagree....how would the clubs know who has the most votes

[Pommy09]

they wont know at all until its annouched at the end of the year

[lisbon lion]

thats my point

[Outlaw 2.0]

Clubs would have a pretty good idea who got the votes not to mention what is said over a few bevvies after the games are said and done

[lisbon lion]

gotta love conspiracy theories

[KING NUGGETT]

The award can only be of Value if it is embraced by all the Players & Clubs,

I dont believe Motts, Cooky, Ebomo or Blacky would not choose the oppositions correct MVP's so there player would win the Award, would you ???

[lisbon lion]

The award can only be of Value if it is embraced by all the Players & Clubs,

I dont believe Motts, Cooky, Ebomo or Blacky would not choose the oppositions correct MVP's so there player would win the Award, would you ???

correct weight....all clear

[Azza]

good idea...I doubt anyone would abuse it...who would want to win an award they didn't win fairly?

[gone]

good idea...I doubt anyone would abuse it...who would want to win an award they didn't win fairly?

[Azza]

good idea...I doubt anyone would abuse it...who would want to win an award they didn't win fairly?

I spose you would ey?

[millsy REF]

you gays talking shite same in the c on both team sheets got 3 2 1

[John Cena]

The reason that this wouldn't work is that for example Elizabeth Downs play Parafield Gardens the last day of the year and Nathan Day has a blinder however if he were to get 3 votes he would leap frog Paul Ebomo for the players player award an win it so Parafield Gardens decide to give the 3 votes to Scott Morrison instead who isn't going to win. This ensures that Paul cannot be leapfrogged and has the best chance of winning the award.

When a ref does it it's an un-biased view on who they thought played the game in the best spirits and contributed most. This enables us to have a result which cannot be tampered with.






***PLEASE NOTE I USED THOSE TWO CLUBS PURELY AS AN EXAMPLE AND IN NO WAY THINK THAT EITHER PARAFIELD GARDENS OR ELIZABETH DOWNS WOULD DO SUCH A THING TO WIN AN AWARD***

careful of your last comment you might get a threat of legal action

[millsy REF]

sue me that is my name on the park i am in charge

[KING NUGGETT]

you gays talking shite same in the c on both team sheets got 3 2 1

WTF are you on about ???

[millsy REF]

YOU KNOW WTF I AM TALKING ABOUT MCNUGGETT

[KING NUGGETT]

Have No FKN idea actually what your on about