Asians and Diving
Moderators: BillShankly, arxidi, Judge Judy, Forum Admins
- Russia2O18
- Star Player
- Posts: 3760
- Joined: Mon Nov 26, 2007 12:22 pm
Asians and Diving
the Chinese are quite good at it...they win many gold medals during the Olympics..even their Super League players dont mind going down somewhat easily
however, my observation of Korean and particularly Japanese teams is they dont do it any more than the top league players in Europe
so painting the whole continent of Asia as divers I think is inaccurate, unfair and ultimately xenophobic by some
however, my observation of Korean and particularly Japanese teams is they dont do it any more than the top league players in Europe
so painting the whole continent of Asia as divers I think is inaccurate, unfair and ultimately xenophobic by some

Re: Asians and Diving
i will admit that some english players do dive but no where near as much as asian leagues
n the asian teams also stay down and waste time more
n the asian teams also stay down and waste time more
- Crocodiles
- Apprentice
- Posts: 215
- Joined: Sat Jul 05, 2008 7:12 am
Re: Asians and Diving
In the Japanese league it's usually the brazillian imports that do it more than the Japanese.
There's people rolling around on the carpet, biting wool and pulling string
- Russia2O18
- Star Player
- Posts: 3760
- Joined: Mon Nov 26, 2007 12:22 pm
Re: Asians and Diving
this is trueCrocodiles wrote:In the Japanese league it's usually the brazillian imports that do it more than the Japanese.

-
- Star Player
- Posts: 3330
- Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 12:47 am
Re: Asians and Diving
Asia is far more than just 3 countries...OnionBag wrote:the Chinese are quite good at it...they win many gold medals during the Olympics..even their Super League players dont mind going down somewhat easily
however, my observation of Korean and particularly Japanese teams is they dont do it any more than the top league players in Europe
so painting the whole continent of Asia as divers I think is inaccurate, unfair and ultimately xenophobic by some
watch some of the smaller nations play (especially against an Australia/South Korea/Japan etc), they're all over the ground
not so much the diving but the rolling around time wasting
I remember seeing Australia vs Bahrain a couple of years ago and we were up 2-0 and they were still wasting time because they didn't want to conceed more goals and mess up their goal difference. It was blatant, pathetic and just plain balls-less
whoever said that the Brazillians are the ones who dive in the J-League and the like though is spot on
that Alexandro or whatever his name was (for Pohang I think) was beyond a joke
-
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 719
- Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2009 9:58 pm
- Russia2O18
- Star Player
- Posts: 3760
- Joined: Mon Nov 26, 2007 12:22 pm
Re: Asians and Diving
yes, but as far as the ACL goes, there's only teams from 3 countries that Melbourne will ever play, China, Korea and JapanLoppermann wrote:Asia is far more than just 3 countries...OnionBag wrote:the Chinese are quite good at it...they win many gold medals during the Olympics..even their Super League players dont mind going down somewhat easily
however, my observation of Korean and particularly Japanese teams is they dont do it any more than the top league players in Europe
so painting the whole continent of Asia as divers I think is inaccurate, unfair and ultimately xenophobic by some
watch some of the smaller nations play (especially against an Australia/South Korea/Japan etc), they're all over the ground
not so much the diving but the rolling around time wasting
I remember seeing Australia vs Bahrain a couple of years ago and we were up 2-0 and they were still wasting time because they didn't want to conceed more goals and mess up their goal difference. It was blatant, pathetic and just plain balls-less
whoever said that the Brazillians are the ones who dive in the J-League and the like though is spot on
that Alexandro or whatever his name was (for Pohang I think) was beyond a joke

Re: Asians and Diving
absolutely disgraceful..... I was sitting near where it happened and you could see clear as day that Vargas didnt touch him...astonvilla91 wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypRMNJgWETA
no surprise to see majority of United 'uneducated' fans went up in arms though....
-
- Star Player
- Posts: 3330
- Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 12:47 am
Re: Asians and Diving
what are you on about, clear penalty, sore loserBlotto wrote:absolutely disgraceful..... I was sitting near where it happened and you could see clear as day that Vargas didnt touch him...astonvilla91 wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypRMNJgWETA
no surprise to see majority of United 'uneducated' fans went up in arms though....
-
- Star Player
- Posts: 3330
- Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 12:47 am
Re: Asians and Diving
South East Asia get the odd club inOnionBag wrote:yes, but as far as the ACL goes, there's only teams from 3 countries that Melbourne will ever play, China, Korea and JapanLoppermann wrote:Asia is far more than just 3 countries...OnionBag wrote:the Chinese are quite good at it...they win many gold medals during the Olympics..even their Super League players dont mind going down somewhat easily
however, my observation of Korean and particularly Japanese teams is they dont do it any more than the top league players in Europe
so painting the whole continent of Asia as divers I think is inaccurate, unfair and ultimately xenophobic by some
watch some of the smaller nations play (especially against an Australia/South Korea/Japan etc), they're all over the ground
not so much the diving but the rolling around time wasting
I remember seeing Australia vs Bahrain a couple of years ago and we were up 2-0 and they were still wasting time because they didn't want to conceed more goals and mess up their goal difference. It was blatant, pathetic and just plain balls-less
whoever said that the Brazillians are the ones who dive in the J-League and the like though is spot on
that Alexandro or whatever his name was (for Pohang I think) was beyond a joke
Re: Asians and Diving
Like the refs in ACL. Pick up rough play and penalise which allows the better players to play. A-League too physical - I want to watch skillful players - any hack can bring someone down when beaten.
Re: Asians and Diving
Loppermann wrote:what are you on about, clear penalty, sore loserBlotto wrote:absolutely disgraceful..... I was sitting near where it happened and you could see clear as day that Vargas didnt touch him...astonvilla91 wrote:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypRMNJgWETA
no surprise to see majority of United 'uneducated' fans went up in arms though....
Melbourne player grabbed Christiano's shirt as he fell though

Makes up for all the shit Muscat gets away with anyway.

-
- Coach
- Posts: 22118
- Joined: Sun Dec 03, 2006 11:42 am
- Has thanked: 234 times
- Been thanked: 67 times
Re: Asians and Diving
I always think the late John Warren had the answer. In the big world competitions and tournaments bring in post match yellow cards after a video review of the game by the four match officials. Sure it would initially result in huge amounts of yellow cards and suspensions but it would quickly rid the game of cheats who dive, shirt pull and hold players in dead ball situations.
Re: Asians and Diving
ozzie owl wrote:I always think the late John Warren had the answer. In the big world competitions and tournaments bring in post match yellow cards after a video review of the game by the four match officials. Sure it would initially result in huge amounts of yellow cards and suspensions but it would quickly rid the game of cheats who dive, shirt pull and hold players in dead ball situations.
agreed

-
- Star Player
- Posts: 3330
- Joined: Tue Feb 23, 2010 12:47 am
Re: Asians and Diving
never happen thoughLitmanen wrote:ozzie owl wrote:I always think the late John Warren had the answer. In the big world competitions and tournaments bring in post match yellow cards after a video review of the game by the four match officials. Sure it would initially result in huge amounts of yellow cards and suspensions but it would quickly rid the game of cheats who dive, shirt pull and hold players in dead ball situations.
agreed