Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

The forum is for discussion of club football outside Australia and national team football Please do not post any offensive or malicious comments.

Moderators: BillShankly, arxidi, Judge Judy, Forum Admins

User avatar
El Pibe D'Oro
Club Captain
Club Captain
Posts: 6172
Joined: Fri May 05, 2006 1:38 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by El Pibe D'Oro »

DOC wrote:i think we found out how big a tool collosus really is in this thread, of course he didn't tell the ref he ran off celebrating, and this is the french captain...

keano junior has it spot on, platini is french so of course he loves it and prob decided the seeding once france were garaunteed a play off spot, its a disgrace... game should be replayed there is that much contraversy to it, and at least these days, unlike 86, we have the technology to erradicate these refereeing errors from the game...

collosus i find it rich you saying keano is bringing the game into disrepute, what has henry done, he created this media storm, he should be banned after the fact like eduardo was...
I dont like the fact that Henry celebrated.

And lets be honest, Blatter the little piglet and Platini would have been delighted with the result. So bringing the game into disrepute....... maybe technically, but I reckon he was spot on.
User avatar
El Pibe D'Oro
Club Captain
Club Captain
Posts: 6172
Joined: Fri May 05, 2006 1:38 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by El Pibe D'Oro »

getborn wrote:
Madridista612 wrote:Wouldn't it be hilarious if France went on to win the World Cup...the world would talk about how they shouldn't have been there, how Platini is a corrupt little puppet in Blatter's monopoly of everything football and basically the whole footballing world would be in an uproar...more so than the infamous hand of God, purely because of Platini's position. It would be something but then again with that muppet Domenech at the helm, France have little to no chance...Spain and Brazil are the only 2 teams I can see lifting it, maybe Italy if theyre lucky.
a madrid supporter, its sure been a while.
Notice that they dont want to talk Madrid subjects.
User avatar
COLOSSUS
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 9944
Joined: Sat Nov 19, 2005 2:13 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by COLOSSUS »

blue moon wrote:colossus if you believe henry, how would you like to buy a part share of the sydney harbour bridge that i've been asked to manage the sale of.

dont know why you keep going on about the chances ireland missed thats got nothing to do with it, its really an issue about the context of the moment (extra time in a w/cup qualifier) and the sportsmanship of an individual at that moment. he's prepared to cheat and he got away with it. to me that reflects on what he is as a person. not excuses in this era of fair play - he makes a mockery of it. his integrity was put to the test and was showed for what it is. how he could look dunne in the eye, i dont know, he's cheated on his fellow professionals. For him to then put the onus on the referree is a cop out. good luck to him hope he enjoys his world cup, i for one hope he get snapped in the first 5-minutes.

wouldnt agree with a replay its basically just very poor referring, how they missed the offiside is as bad as the handball and unfortunately this is football - but he would have shown himself to be a true sportsman if he owned up to the referree.
You just dont get it do you??? Its not about believing Henry, for farks sake its not even about Henry. Did he score directly from the handball??? No he didnt. This is about you people harping on 1 moment of a game that went for over 90 friken minutes. Why not harp on every single moment that Ireland had in front of goal because thats what cost them, not Thierry Henry. That handball would not even be mentioned if Ireland had won that game but because they lost, they choose to harp on it, what a load of rubbish. You question Henrys sportsmanship on one incident??? Well congratulations, because if Henry is to be judged by you on one MINOR incident for his whole entire Footballing career then i feel sorry for you and you arent someone to reason with. Henry isnt there to look dunne in the eyes, nor is he there to play to the same standards of his fellow professionals, he is there to help France whichever way he can, just like Dunne is there to help Ireland whichever way he can. Do we now call every Footballer that has ever handled a ball, dived in the box, pulled on a shirt (which by the way we call professional foul :wink: ), purposely brought down outside the box (which we also call a professional foul :wink: ) as CHEATS??? Because that is what ultimately you are implying and that is so wrong its not funny. Get over it blue moon, it was one incident in one game that went for over 90 minutes. How about the referee and his assistant, how about the Irish finishing, how about the Irish coach, how about those things, did they not contribute??? Or did the whole game revolve around one friken incident??? :roll: :roll: :roll:
Hawkesy wrote:COLOSSUS...........Congratulations, you have won the title fair a square.

PLEASE WELCOME THE NEW WNID UP KING
User avatar
# 9
Star Player
Star Player
Posts: 4698
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2007 10:13 am

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by # 9 »

haha ur a joke colossus
Image
User avatar
COLOSSUS
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 9944
Joined: Sat Nov 19, 2005 2:13 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by COLOSSUS »

A R S H A V I N wrote:haha ur a joke colossus
possibly your right, but at least i offer reasons behind my opinions :wink: When you decide to also, then come talk to me, until then finish your homework, hopefully doesnt take you too long to do your times (x) tables :roll:
Hawkesy wrote:COLOSSUS...........Congratulations, you have won the title fair a square.

PLEASE WELCOME THE NEW WNID UP KING
BADA BING
Star Player
Star Player
Posts: 2995
Joined: Thu Apr 26, 2007 2:59 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by BADA BING »

getborn wrote:
Madridista612 wrote:Wouldn't it be hilarious if France went on to win the World Cup...the world would talk about how they shouldn't have been there, how Platini is a corrupt little puppet in Blatter's monopoly of everything football and basically the whole footballing world would be in an uproar...more so than the infamous hand of God, purely because of Platini's position. It would be something but then again with that muppet Domenech at the helm, France have little to no chance...Spain and Brazil are the only 2 teams I can see lifting it, maybe Italy if theyre lucky.
a madrid supporter, its sure been a while.
I was thinking the same thing this morning
User avatar
ruud
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 13172
Joined: Thu Mar 30, 2006 11:18 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by ruud »

BADA BING wrote:
getborn wrote:
Madridista612 wrote:Wouldn't it be hilarious if France went on to win the World Cup...the world would talk about how they shouldn't have been there, how Platini is a corrupt little puppet in Blatter's monopoly of everything football and basically the whole footballing world would be in an uproar...more so than the infamous hand of God, purely because of Platini's position. It would be something but then again with that muppet Domenech at the helm, France have little to no chance...Spain and Brazil are the only 2 teams I can see lifting it, maybe Italy if theyre lucky.
a madrid supporter, its sure been a while.
I was thinking the same thing this morning
Image
User avatar
pires7
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 8994
Joined: Mon May 14, 2007 9:15 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by pires7 »

It's stiff s*** now! no way should their be a replay or FIFA will be replaying every singe match with a c**k up in it for years to come.
User avatar
Il Duce
Boot Polisher
Boot Polisher
Posts: 99
Joined: Wed Jul 09, 2008 8:21 am

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by Il Duce »

pires7 wrote:It's stiff s*** now! no way should their be a replay or FIFA will be replaying every singe match with a c**k up in it for years to come.
I have to agree there should not be a replay, but FIFA did order Uzbekistan and Bahrain to replay their qualifier four years ago after a japanese referee made a major coçk up. Bahrain who were rightfully beaten in the original tie won the replay so I was glad they lost out to New Zealand this time.
blue moon
Squad Player
Squad Player
Posts: 1226
Joined: Mon Aug 16, 2004 8:34 am
Been thanked: 2 times

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by blue moon »

You just dont get it do you??? Its not about believing Henry, for farks sake its not even about Henry. Did he score directly from the handball??? No he didnt. This is about you people harping on 1 moment of a game that went for over 90 friken minutes. Why not harp on every single moment that Ireland had in front of goal because thats what cost them, not Thierry Henry. That handball would not even be mentioned if Ireland had won that game but because they lost, they choose to harp on it, what a load of rubbish. You question Henrys sportsmanship on one incident??? Well congratulations, because if Henry is to be judged by you on one MINOR incident for his whole entire Footballing career then i feel sorry for you and you arent someone to reason with. Henry isnt there to look dunne in the eyes, nor is he there to play to the same standards of his fellow professionals, he is there to help France whichever way he can, just like Dunne is there to help Ireland whichever way he can. Do we now call every Footballer that has ever handled a ball, dived in the box, pulled on a shirt (which by the way we call professional foul :wink: ), purposely brought down outside the box (which we also call a professional foul :wink: ) as CHEATS??? Because that is what ultimately you are implying and that is so wrong its not funny. Get over it blue moon, it was one incident in one game that went for over 90 minutes. How about the referee and his assistant, how about the Irish finishing, how about the Irish coach, how about those things, did they not contribute??? Or did the whole game revolve around one friken incident??? :roll: :roll: :roll:[/quote]

no you just dont get it. its about a split moment in the dying moments of a game after two teams have played evenly for probably two years over a dozen games and still then goes to extra time. its the context of the moment - one person makes a decision to blatently cheat in order to get his team over the line when they havnt been able to before. it just says so much about a persons sportsmanship and their real qualities as a person when put on the spot at the crucial moment. its like a cricketer claiming a catch when he knows its bounced to win a test match, get the result but lose as a person. some people just find that acceptable and thats fine, personally myself a lot of other people dont. i'm not pro irish just a neutral, i'm sure they wouldnt have had to much sympathy if it were england on the end of the decision.
fowlerisgod
Promising Junior
Promising Junior
Posts: 386
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2007 12:19 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by fowlerisgod »

what would have happened if it was robbie keane who handled and knocked france out in extra time?
User avatar
COLOSSUS
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 9944
Joined: Sat Nov 19, 2005 2:13 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by COLOSSUS »

fowlerisgod wrote:what would have happened if it was robbie keane who handled and knocked france out in extra time?
Would never happen according to redfred,
redfred wrote:must be the anglo mentality col..............bloody foreigners always seeking to gain an advantage...we believe in fair play
Im not sure however what he meant by foreigners because as i remember the game in Paris, the foreigners were those complaining at the end of it :wink: But i think i get the jist of it, people from the UK are fair and always will be :lol: :roll:
Hawkesy wrote:COLOSSUS...........Congratulations, you have won the title fair a square.

PLEASE WELCOME THE NEW WNID UP KING
M160RA
Bench Warmer
Bench Warmer
Posts: 583
Joined: Sun Nov 23, 2008 3:01 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by M160RA »

COLOSSUS wrote:[
redfred wrote:must be the anglo mentality col..............bloody foreigners always seeking to gain an advantage...we believe in fair play
Im not sure however what he meant by foreigners because as i remember the game in Paris, the foreigners were those complaining at the end of it :wink: But i think i get the jist of it, people from the UK are fair and always will be :lol: :roll:
You've already been found to be a hypocrite, now I understand it stems from your xenophobia. Funny how both undesirable characteristics are from the greek language. :lol:
Manchester United, not arrogant, just better.
fowlerisgod
Promising Junior
Promising Junior
Posts: 386
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2007 12:19 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by fowlerisgod »

If it did happen, I'm sure platini would be finding a way to have a replay or invent a new rule where unfair play means disqualification. I'm generally not big on conspiracy theories but what was wrong about the playoff draw was the seedings. There was no seedings done prior in other playoff games so why this year? If anything maybe ireland should have been seeded as they went undefeated through the group stage which included the world champions. I wouldn't go as far to say that the ref's had an agenda though, if they did the dive from anelka certainly would have been a penalty :wink: I don't think it matters where the player is from, its down to individual player doing the action. I know what robbie would have done :wink:
kmaau
Bench Warmer
Bench Warmer
Posts: 869
Joined: Thu Jan 10, 2008 10:29 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by kmaau »

COLOSSUS wrote:
A R S H A V I N wrote:haha ur a joke colossus
possibly your right, but at least i offer reasons behind my opinions :wink: When you decide to also, then come talk to me, until then finish your homework, hopefully doesnt take you too long to do your times (x) tables :roll:
Colossus , you must not use logic -you make too many people look silly.

Facts are: 1. Henry committed a foul.
a) If the ref did his job right, he would have given a free kick (and maybe a yellow ticket).
During the game , the ref would have given a number of free kicks.
Are all the players who did a foul during the game "bad sportsmen" or "cheats"? No
If ref ruled a foul against Henry,does this make Henry a bad s/man or cheat? No

b)Did Henry have any control over refs decision? No

Therefore anyone calling Henry a cheat is pointing the finger at the wrong man.

2. Keane has clearly brought the game into disrepute. In fact,some would say he has been defamatory.
barbarez01
Squad Player
Squad Player
Posts: 1262
Joined: Sun Aug 27, 2006 6:30 pm

Re: Keane blasts Blatter, Platini

Post by barbarez01 »

finally someone has a go at them, if this happened to Bosnia no one would have heard of it.. so im glad in a way that it happened to Ireland a much more recognised/respected country....
Image
Sejad Salihovic!!
Post Reply