Cup Round 2 Results

[Europa League]

The referee did not lawfully say the game was over after 5 penalties. The game was decided after 7 penalties each which Playford won.

Exactly whcih shouldnt have been done.

[Barney Rubble]

Oh dear,

[rooboy1986]

The referee did not lawfully say the game was over after 5 penalties. The game was decided after 7 penalties each which Playford won.

Exactly whcih shouldnt have been done.

I think a nice letter to the FFSA will sort the issue out... sounds like a bit of a stuff up... at worst a replay of the match, at best game awarded to West Adelaide... if the facts on here are in fact correct.

[Juventus]

Does anyone know these 16 cup results?

Campbelltown vs Adelaide Hills

Salisbury vs Noarlunga

Modbury vs Raiders

Birkalla vs Croydon 1

Also, what was Modbury 17's final result?

[mots]

The referee did not lawfully say the game was over after 5 penalties. The game was decided after 7 penalties each which Playford won.

Exactly whcih shouldnt have been done.

I think a nice letter to the FFSA will sort the issue out... sounds like a bit of a stuff up... at worst a replay of the match, at best game awarded to West Adelaide... if the facts on here are in fact correct.

So...how many penalty kicks did they take???

Rule has been the same for many years now, ref show know them as should coaches etc.

7.7 In the event of a draw at the end of normal time For JPL Cup competitions from Under 12 to Under
16, a 5 minute interval shall be taken followed by 10 minutes of extra time each way. Following
this if the match is still a draw, the result shall be decided by penalty kicks under the FIFA Laws of
the Game.

FIFA laws of the game...you keep taking penalty kicks until you have a winner (if still level after 5)

[rabbit]

The referee did not lawfully say the game was over after 5 penalties. The game was decided after 7 penalties each which Playford won.

My sources tell me that after 5 penalties it was 3-3 as recorded by the referee. I also am led to believe that the Playford player who took the 5th penalty, in fact scored. This is the real dispute that needs to tidied up. I'm sure both Coaches could clear this one up. If I was an opposing Coach, I reckon I'd know the score after 5 penalties. Anyone take video footage?

[pulse]

At the end of the game, which team was celebrating the win?

[rabbit]

Playford and west Adelaide apparantly........ :?

[YNWA_7]

At the end of the game, which team was celebrating the win?

west adelaide boys ran to the penalty taker to celebrate after they won 3-2 in 5 penalties by both teams.

playford won out of 7 penalties and celebrated after that

[Squizzy]

Playford U15's won on penalties against West Adelaide. Referee judged Playford the winners. Celebrations and handshakes done by each team - no problems.
Then as players were leaving ref comes out of her changeroom 10 minutes later WITH 2 WEST ADELAIDE people one being their linesman and said she thought she MAY have made a mistake. This was cleared up after a bit of discussion with the coaches however she said was intimidated by the West Adelaide people and the result stood as Playford winning.

Doesn't surprise me at all.

[JUSTDOIT]

Does anyone know these 16 cup results?

Campbelltown vs Adelaide Hills

Salisbury vs Noarlunga

Modbury vs Raiders

Birkalla vs Croydon 1

Also, what was Modbury 17's final result?

16s

Modbury 7-1 Raiders

17s

Modbury 1-1 Blue Eagles (after extra time)

Blue Eagles won 4-3 on penalties

[pulse]

In the 13s match between Campbelltown and Raiders, the Raiders trainer was screaming out 'take them out' when the team was losing 6-0.

I was disgusted when I heard that coming from their bench, no one wants to condone those actions on the playing field especially at such a young age.

[Nova]

U14A - Modbury 0-3 Campbelltown

[Filikis Eterias]

Simple, the referee admitted to miscounting. West lead after 5 penalties each by 3 goals to 2. FFSA will ultimately rule in Wests favour.
If it was the other way around we would have graciously accepted defeat.
No need to make a big deal out of it. The young female referee was never intimidated by our officials as alleged by a previous poster. Once she checked her book she saw her mistake.

[Filikis Eterias]

Playford U15's won on penalties against West Adelaide. Referee judged Playford the winners. Celebrations and handshakes done by each team - no problems.
Then as players were leaving ref comes out of her changeroom 10 minutes later WITH 2 WEST ADELAIDE people one being their linesman and said she thought she MAY have made a mistake. This was cleared up after a bit of discussion with the coaches however she said was intimidated by the West Adelaide people and the result stood as Playford winning.

Doesn't surprise me at all.

Thats a smart comment coming from a Campbelltown coach, Mr Big Mouth himself.

[Black Hawk]

U16 Cup
Campbelltown 0 Hawks 5

[manu17]

U/16's Croydon lost to Birkalla, 2-2 after extra time and then 4-1 on penalties.

[mail man]

U16 Cup
Campbelltown 0 Hawks 5

Couldn't Campbelltown stack their team with 17's players like round 1?
Well of course they couldn't because they were cup tied this time!

[Juventus]

What was the U16 Salisbury vs Noarlunga score?

[The Wise Monkey]

U16s Noarlunga 1 Salisbury 5

[ballmaster]

Croydon 14A 6 - Para Hills 4B 0

[ballmaster]

Croydon 14A 6 - Para Hills 14B 0

[Squizzy]

Playford U15's won on penalties against West Adelaide. Referee judged Playford the winners. Celebrations and handshakes done by each team - no problems.
Then as players were leaving ref comes out of her changeroom 10 minutes later WITH 2 WEST ADELAIDE people one being their linesman and said she thought she MAY have made a mistake. This was cleared up after a bit of discussion with the coaches however she said was intimidated by the West Adelaide people and the result stood as Playford winning.

Doesn't surprise me at all.

Thats a smart comment coming from a Campbelltown coach, Mr Big Mouth himself.

Funny comment coming from you. My original comment still stands.

But seriously, good luck.

[Liverpool!]

Regarding Playford West Adelaide result in penalty shoot out:
Playford goal West miss
Playford miss West goal
Playford miss West miss
Playford miss West goal
Playford goal West goal disallowed (kicked before whistle)
Golden Goal:
Playford goal West miss PLAYFORD WINS MATCH
(Referee mistakenly called for second Playford shot (goal, but irrelevant to outcome)
Disallowed goal was not clearly announced which possibly led to dispute.

[rooboy1986]

Regarding Playford West Adelaide result in penalty shoot out:
Playford goal West miss
Playford miss West goal
Playford miss West miss
Playford miss West goal
Playford goal West goal disallowed (kicked before whistle)Golden Goal:
Playford goal West miss PLAYFORD WINS MATCH
(Referee mistakenly called for second Playford shot (goal, but irrelevant to outcome)
Disallowed goal was not clearly announced which possibly led to dispute.

Cannot be disallowed, must be re-taken if this scenario in fact happened the way you say... I smell a re-match on the cards...

[Green_Manalishi]

Regarding Playford West Adelaide result in penalty shoot out:
Playford goal West miss
Playford miss West goal
Playford miss West miss
Playford miss West goal
Playford goal West goal disallowed (kicked before whistle)
Golden Goal:
Playford goal West miss PLAYFORD WINS MATCH
(Referee mistakenly called for second Playford shot (goal, but irrelevant to outcome)
Disallowed goal was not clearly announced which possibly led to dispute.

If correct this sounds a lot more plausible than the version posted by the West Adelaide supporters and shows that a convenient little detail was left out. While the ref definitely erred, it appears it was not 3-2 after 5 penalties as claimed and a propensity to not play to the whistle may have cost them dearly.

In all the excitement Playford's efforts in holding an A team to a draw appears to have been largely overlooked. Was it 0-0 ?

[Barney Rubble]

Regarding Playford West Adelaide result in penalty shoot out:
Playford goal West miss 1 - 0
Playford miss West goal 1 - 1
Playford miss West miss 1 - 1
Playford miss West goal 1 - 2
Playford goal West goal disallowed (kicked before whistle) 2 - 2
Golden Goal:
Playford goal West miss PLAYFORD WINS MATCH - Wrong sequence - 2 - 2
(Referee mistakenly called for second Playford shot (goal, but irrelevant to outcome)
Disallowed goal was not clearly announced which possibly led to dispute.

At last THE TRUTH . . . . . but can we handle it

Interesting indeed

Look i am not throwing stones here but would the coaches / managers not realise the error made
In the heat of the moment agreed it can get to be a HUGE adrenalin rush but . . . . logic

Seems like some coaches need to practice penalties

new topic i think

[Liverpool!]

Last comment re Playford West Adelaide game. It was a draw at 0-0.

[Željko Jurin]

In the 13s match between Campbelltown and Raiders, the Raiders trainer was screaming out 'take them out' when the team was losing 6-0.

I was disgusted when I heard that coming from their bench, no one wants to condone those actions on the playing field especially at such a young age.

Sad if true

You said trainer, is that the coach, young guy with black hair, or someone else ???

[Europa League]

Regarding Playford West Adelaide result in penalty shoot out:
Playford goal West miss
Playford miss West goal
Playford miss West miss
Playford miss West goal
Playford goal West goal disallowed (kicked before whistle)
Golden Goal:
Playford goal West miss PLAYFORD WINS MATCH
(Referee mistakenly called for second Playford shot (goal, but irrelevant to outcome)
Disallowed goal was not clearly announced which possibly led to dispute.

We're in gods name did you find the dissalowed penalty from?? The was not one penalty dissalowed in the shootout, There was a penalty dissalowed during normal time for being kicked before the whistle so did u just shove this penalty in the shootout and take it out of normal time?