Why have players left Modbury ?

wizards · Post by **wizards** » Tue Dec 04, 2007 8:01 pm

Just a bit curious to know why players selected during trials, end up leaving and going to another Club. Whats wrong with Modbury ?

strawney · Post by **strawney** » Tue Dec 04, 2007 8:23 pm

This happens at all the Clubs, Some players move on for different reasons. ( coach, friends etc ).

wizards · Post by **wizards** » Tue Dec 04, 2007 8:46 pm

Was told the Coach for the 16`s 2007 has been the biggest problem ?
Players from other age groups below didn`t want to play for him if he was
selected as 17`s coach.
Is this True ?

povman_2009 · Post by **povman_2009** » Tue Dec 11, 2007 2:27 pm

Wizards, when you answer your own question it seems a bit pointless, why not just say what you know and be done with it.

Players trial at several clubs and then pick one after they get offers, it is a free market so the clubs have to work hard to make a good environment for kids / parents to want to be involved in.

The coach is a large part of that , but many other factors come into it as well.

Karicako · Post by **Karicako** » Tue Dec 11, 2007 7:40 pm

Hmm... I heard it was the Coach too. But only hear say though.

sir · Post by **sir** » Tue Dec 11, 2007 7:44 pm

Just a bit curious to know why players selected during trials, end up leaving and going to another Club. Whats wrong with Modbury ?

Which players in particular are you talking about?????

Sounds like a bit of shiraz stirring against modbury AGAIN as if modbury is the only club that this happens to. I think not....

liverpool_08 · Post by **liverpool_08** » Tue Dec 11, 2007 10:08 pm

sir wrote:Just a bit curious to know why players selected during trials, end up leaving and going to another Club. Whats wrong with Modbury ?

Which players in particular are you talking about?????

Sounds like a bit of shiraz stirring against modbury AGAIN as if modbury is the only club that this happens to. I think not....

agreed!

Modbury is the only one that people talk about

why not other clubs?!?!?

Modbury dont deserve it! :?

Barney Rubble · Post by **Barney Rubble** » Wed Dec 12, 2007 10:13 pm

sir wrote:Just a bit curious to know why players selected during trials, end up leaving and going to another Club. Whats wrong with Modbury ?

Which players in particular are you talking about?????

Sounds like a bit of shiraz stirring against modbury AGAIN as if modbury is the only club that this happens to. I think not....

Dear Sir

Sorry couldn't resist that one

(gonna get the cane again my boy!)

seeing only 2 posts including this one allows me to give a bit of advice, for free.

Your question is discussed time and time again on this forum at the end of the season.
Lots of reasons why, ranging from PARENTS, players - naturally - and loyalty from clubs & players.
The latter being the lack of it on BOTH parties over the years.

Fair question, though

and like Liverpool_08 said, it is not just Modbury.

Been and seen both sides of the fence.

anyway i see the price of a sliced loaf has gone up by 10 cents this week :?

rabbit · Post by **rabbit** » Thu Dec 13, 2007 1:57 pm

wizards wrote:Just a bit curious to know why players selected during trials, end up leaving and going to another Club. Whats wrong with Modbury ?

Nothing wrong with Modbury at all.....gives us enormous pleasure playing them every year

Barney Rubble · Post by **Barney Rubble** » Thu Dec 13, 2007 10:50 pm

rabbit wrote:
wizards wrote:Just a bit curious to know why players selected during trials, end up leaving and going to another Club. Whats wrong with Modbury ?

Nothing wrong with Modbury at all.....gives us enormous pleasure playing them every year

Take the shirts of their backs too Eh Rabbitt

rabbit · Post by **rabbit** » Thu Dec 13, 2007 10:54 pm

Love it Barney, nice work.

Barney Rubble · Post by **Barney Rubble** » Thu Dec 13, 2007 11:00 pm

I suppose you had to be there

Still got some of your beers in the fridge, best bring Whilma over and finish them off one evening

Geez the new season is nearly here !

rabbit · Post by **rabbit** » Thu Dec 13, 2007 11:21 pm

No probs...we've not stopped since trials but now will break until 11/1/08.
Nearly bored already....

sad eh?

SID · Post by **SID** » Sun Dec 16, 2007 10:10 am

Hey wizards if you left coz ya didnt like the coach then good for you son..... No player at any level is bigger than the club and it is the club that appoints the coaches, if people aren't happy then shut up and move on...... Modbury as always will carry on and make decisions that at time will prove to be good and at times prove to be bad. That is just the way Football is....

robinfriday10 · Post by **robinfriday10** » Sun Dec 16, 2007 10:10 pm

some players are bigger!! more bad than good decisions!! look down the road , better decision makin done!!

SID · Post by **SID** » Mon Dec 17, 2007 10:03 am

why bad decisions robin? your lad plays there doesnt he?

robinfriday10 · Post by **robinfriday10** » Wed Dec 19, 2007 10:55 pm

got one boot in each camp this year

all clubs make good and bad decisions(as read daily on here!) just cause 1 lad plays there doesnt mean i agree with decisions..also doesn't mean i dislike the club, as you may know i'm neutral these days

theone · Post by **theone** » Thu Dec 20, 2007 7:34 am

for all those knocking Modbury what about the 30 or so players they have recruited and you also need to get your heads out of the sand if you think it is one club. If you are so dismayed by the decisions made by any club get of you backsides and go and do something about it join the committee! - or is it to much like hard work.

You will see what running a club is all about then - were not playing because of the coach, I'm not paying for that, whay is my son not playing as much as him, I'm not running the BBQ I payed nearly $500. Then maybe you will understand EVERY club makes decisions bad or good if you are not happy play elsewhere.

No one player or person is bigger than the club and most clubs make desicions based on what they belive is good for the club.

As for players leaving duiring trials If you are selected in a team and you as a parent do not have the curtesy/guts to advise a club/coach you are trialing/going elsewhere I see that as a parent issue not a player issue.

At the end of the day we as parents do what we feel is best for our sons/daughters and base that on all the information we have in front of us I know many a parent who has got it wrong and many who got it right don't highlight one club over another many a story could be told about any club you want to mention.

stargazer · Post by **stargazer** » Thu Dec 20, 2007 8:37 am

theone wrote:for all those knocking Modbury what about the 30 or so players they have recruited and you also need to get your heads out of the sand if you think it is one club. If you are so dismayed by the decisions made by any club get of you backsides and go and do something about it join the committee! - or is it to much like hard work.

You will see what running a club is all about then - were not playing because of the coach, I'm not paying for that, whay is my son not playing as much as him, I'm not running the BBQ I payed nearly $500. Then maybe you will understand EVERY club makes decisions bad or good if you are not happy play elsewhere.

No one player or person is bigger than the club and most clubs make desicions based on what they belive is good for the club.

As for players leaving duiring trials If you are selected in a team and you as a parent do not have the curtesy/guts to advise a club/coach you are trialing/going elsewhere I see that as a parent issue not a player issue.

At the end of the day we as parents do what we feel is best for our sons/daughters and base that on all the information we have in front of us I know many a parent who has got it wrong and many who got it right don't highlight one club over another many a story could be told about any club you want to mention.

Absolutely, spot on!

SILENT P · Post by **SILENT P** » Thu Dec 20, 2007 8:38 am

theone, I agree. My biggest issue with players is that they want to be treated with respect but they won't do the same to the coaches.

On many occassions I have selected a player but have found out by other sources that they have decided to play for another club. What is wrong with a phone call!!!!

Fabregas_hero · Post by **Fabregas_hero** » Sun Jan 27, 2008 10:47 pm

Fair few modbury players have left for campbelltown
also i hav heard many of the 16s players made 17s bt preferd to play 16s

Barney Rubble · Post by **Barney Rubble** » Sun Jan 27, 2008 11:36 pm

think you may need a hearing aid

Hollygirl · Post by **Hollygirl** » Mon Jan 28, 2008 12:24 pm

Fabregas_hero wrote:Fair few modbury players have left for campbelltown
also i hav heard many of the 16s players made 17s bt preferd to play 16s

Never heard of players prefering to play 16's than 17's before

theone · Post by **theone** » Mon Jan 28, 2008 1:57 pm

Febergas only 2 maybe 3 went to Campbelltown and they followed thier coach from the previsous year who was at Modbury which they are entilteled to do and I dont think anybody has an issue with that.

There were no players in the 17s that stayed have dropped down.

The U16 players opted to play for the U16 (moving up from 15s in most cases) for there own reasons those that left chose to or there parents chose for them to leave for what ever reason.

The coach has gone a new coach is in place the club has some very good coaches so lets start looking elsewhere for our entertainment!

Barney Rubble · Post by **Barney Rubble** » Mon Jan 28, 2008 4:01 pm

agreed, i mean the season has not even started yet

Fabregas_hero · Post by **Fabregas_hero** » Mon Jan 28, 2008 9:16 pm

There actually is 2 17s that got in and 1 playd 17s last year and i kno some of the blokes so get ur facts straight

theone · Post by **theone** » Thu Jan 31, 2008 8:10 am

So you are involved with the club and know all that is going on or your a friend of a friend of a friend within the club. Did these friends trial for the 17s or did they make the decesion they did not want to because of the coach which they have every right as any player/parent does. I assume they decided to play for the U16 or left the club which is also there choice.

If they did not trial then how do you select them if they did trial then right or wrong the coach did not pick them but they now have a new coach who appears to be very good so lefe will go on.

Dont worry all enquire tonight and try to find out why they were not selected so I can get my facts right.

theone · Post by **theone** » Thu Jan 31, 2008 8:13 am

If they made the U17 and decided to leave becuase of reason XYZ that is also there option but I will check which 16s got selected and dropped down to play in 16s

rabbit · Post by **rabbit** » Thu Jan 31, 2008 3:11 pm

Dumb topic gone stale.....move on

citynumeruno · Post by **citynumeruno** » Wed Feb 13, 2008 4:55 pm

well do u wnt to know the truth,

the under 17s coach was the hole big fuckin problem,

thank god he fuckn left.

he shouldnt even gone for the job.

thats what v'e been told by a few 17s players

the players left cause none of the 17s that played last year, didnt wnt to be coached under a fuck head

Home | Forums | Photos | Video | Blog | About | Contact

Why have players left Modbury ?

Why have players left Modbury ?

Re: Why have players left Modbury ?

Re: Why have players left Modbury ?

get your head out of the sand

Re: get your head out of the sand