Fergie support for Blatter stance on imports

The forum is for discussion of club football outside Australia and national team football Please do not post any offensive or malicious comments.

Moderators: BillShankly, arxidi, Judge Judy, Forum Admins

User avatar
Le King
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 12235
Joined: Tue Nov 11, 2003 6:24 pm

Post by Le King »

atleast u talk sense rigoni... that otha bloke has no idea
User avatar
pires7
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 8994
Joined: Mon May 14, 2007 9:15 pm

Post by pires7 »

Rigoni 10 wrote:
MUFCBOY wrote:
pires7 wrote:
MUFCBOY wrote:
pires7 wrote:the side is pretty much balanced! Business is still business, we dont want to buy a player for 10million to warm the bench! Any player we could buy this year won't get a game unless we bought them from another big 4 club!

Outide of this cant think of too many players in the league good enough to make our side!
i could think of atleast 5

gerrard, rooney, ronaldo, terry, cech, drogba.... thats 6, ill stop there
and i'm only talking englishmen
gerrard, terry, lampard, rooney, scholes, richards, rio
i'd only have richards, gerrard, terry, rooney, scholes
there is ZERO chance that Man U, Chelsea of Liverpool will sell us a player, unless they are finished! Name any other english players not at these clubs that could get a game!
Richards is one for the future but is cleary overated at the moment! Why in the world should we pay 20million for him when Toure and Gallas are better, more experienced players! and he wouldn't start in our back four anyways! He was found out big time v Chelsea, Drogba gave him a bath!
Colonel Trautman
Ball Boy
Ball Boy
Posts: 29
Joined: Thu Nov 08, 2007 10:19 am

Post by Colonel Trautman »

In 'nam, VC side P. Sông Lam Nghệ An FC had trouble with this, as rival club Lam Nhe Song P Lam Cream O Sum Yung Gai had a few imported players. The trouble was that P.Song didnt have the physical attributes as the other team and werent as techinically gifted, luckily, I had rambo go in there and clean the place out.

Point is, imported players make the league better. Not local players.
Image
BAGGIO 15
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 15214
Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2005 1:58 pm
Has thanked: 5 times
Been thanked: 10 times

Post by BAGGIO 15 »

Colonel Trautman wrote:In 'nam, VC side P. Sông Lam Nghệ An FC had trouble with this, as rival club Lam Nhe Song P Lam Cream O Sum Yung Gai had a few imported players. The trouble was that P.Song didnt have the physical attributes as the other team and werent as techinically gifted, luckily, I had rambo go in there and clean the place out.

Point is, imported players make the league better. Not local players.
Betterfor who?
For the English fan until that same fan bitches that the national team are shite and why can't they with one of the best leagues win or get close to winning something.
User avatar
Judge Judy
Technical Director
Technical Director
Posts: 35566
Joined: Wed May 15, 2002 7:55 pm

Post by Judge Judy »

i do agree that arsenal should have more english players in the squad, but do not agree that they should be forced to pay stupid money just for the sake of having them at the club.

however, i also do not care if english national team continue to fail
Ingle Farm Amateur Soccer Club
Website: http://ifasc.com.au
Twitter: http://twitter.com/ifasc
Facebook: http://facebook.com/ifasc
BAGGIO 15
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 15214
Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2005 1:58 pm
Has thanked: 5 times
Been thanked: 10 times

Post by BAGGIO 15 »

ibax wrote:i do agree that arsenal should have more english players in the squad, but do not agree that they should be forced to pay stupid money just for the sake of having them at the club.

however, i also do not care if english national team continue to fail

I haven't metioned to $$$ value of players as many are over priced and they need to be value for money after all.

I use the English team as an example, I also like seeing them acheive nothing. Italy as WC champs are the exception, but England and Spain under acheive due to the current rules. Inter is doing itself no favours as they could play a big part in developing the next crop of Azzurri stars.

Most smaller nations benefit as they have more players oversea's, but the best will always go. What benefit is it if most of our players ( Australia ) play championship football, it could be argued that the A League would be better there for the local leagues would be better. Better product and possible more sponsorship $$$$
Police Deputy Mitch
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 220
Joined: Sat May 12, 2007 4:13 pm

Post by Police Deputy Mitch »

BAGGIO 15 wrote:
Colonel Trautman wrote:In 'nam, VC side P. Sông Lam Nghệ An FC had trouble with this, as rival club Lam Nhe Song P Lam Cream O Sum Yung Gai had a few imported players. The trouble was that P.Song didnt have the physical attributes as the other team and werent as techinically gifted, luckily, I had rambo go in there and clean the place out.

Point is, imported players make the league better. Not local players.
Betterfor who?
For the English fan until that same fan bitches that the national team are shite and why can't they with one of the best leagues win or get close to winning something.
I want, what they want, and every other foreigner who came over here to England and spilled his guts and gave everything he had, wants! For this country to love us as much as we love it! That's what I want!
Image
E. Grant & Co
Star Player
Star Player
Posts: 2853
Joined: Fri Sep 21, 2007 4:31 pm

Post by E. Grant & Co »

Baggio> there in lies a problem for young Australian players. If the European clubs are forced to use a % of local players, that in turn will mean imported players won't be used by them. Hence they, the imported, will be forced to stay and play in their own back yard, which is good for us supporters. There is no doubt that the A League this year is missing out on seeing the talents of the likes of David Carney etc etc.

Would Nathan Burns be better off playing in a lesser league in Europe than staying here in the A League, playing regularly in the ACL plus possibly with Australia qualifying for the world cup every 4 years, I know what the answer would be.

This is a decision in the best interests of the sport, definately not in the best interests of the major clubs around the world.

It would be interesting to see the stats on the number of imports [as a % factor] in all of the major leagues around the world then compare them to the J league, K League, A league etc etc
User avatar
Le King
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 12235
Joined: Tue Nov 11, 2003 6:24 pm

Post by Le King »

pires7 wrote:
Rigoni 10 wrote:
MUFCBOY wrote:
pires7 wrote:
MUFCBOY wrote:
pires7 wrote:the side is pretty much balanced! Business is still business, we dont want to buy a player for 10million to warm the bench! Any player we could buy this year won't get a game unless we bought them from another big 4 club!

Outide of this cant think of too many players in the league good enough to make our side!
i could think of atleast 5

gerrard, rooney, ronaldo, terry, cech, drogba.... thats 6, ill stop there
and i'm only talking englishmen
gerrard, terry, lampard, rooney, scholes, richards, rio
i'd only have richards, gerrard, terry, rooney, scholes
there is ZERO chance that Man U, Chelsea of Liverpool will sell us a player, unless they are finished! Name any other english players not at these clubs that could get a game!
Richards is one for the future but is cleary overated at the moment! Why in the world should we pay 20million for him when Toure and Gallas are better, more experienced players! and he wouldn't start in our back four anyways! He was found out big time v Chelsea, Drogba gave him a bath!
lol here we go again, changin the question this time, u sed any englishment, u didnt say any englishmen that rnt in the top 4... in black ive highlighted wat u sed and i answered it... dont go changin ur original question
BAGGIO 15
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 15214
Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2005 1:58 pm
Has thanked: 5 times
Been thanked: 10 times

Post by BAGGIO 15 »

neworder wrote:Baggio> there in lies a problem for young Australian players. If the European clubs are forced to use a % of local players, that in turn will mean imported players won't be used by them. Hence they, the imported, will be forced to stay and play in their own back yard, which is good for us supporters. There is no doubt that the A League this year is missing out on seeing the talents of the likes of David Carney etc etc.

Would Nathan Burns be better off playing in a lesser league in Europe than staying here in the A League, playing regularly in the ACL plus possibly with Australia qualifying for the world cup every 4 years, I know what the answer would be.
This is a decision in the best interests of the sport, definately not in the best interests of the major clubs around the world.
It would be interesting to see the stats on the number of imports [as a % factor] in all of the major leagues around the world then compare them to the J league, K League, A league etc etc
If this rule came in he wouldn't get into a lesser league in Europe as their best would be playing domesticly. If he did it would be good for him, but the A league and all ACL clubs would be even stronger.

As for what I highlighted in red I agree.
User avatar
Hawkesy
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 16451
Joined: Wed Feb 07, 2007 2:02 pm

Post by Hawkesy »

BAGGIO 15 wrote:If this rule came in he wouldn't get into a lesser league in Europe as their best would be playing domesticly. If he did it would be good for him, but the A league and all ACL clubs would be even stronger.
He'd probably get a game at Fisher Athletic, so could play a similar standard but get more money.
BAGGIO 15
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 15214
Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2005 1:58 pm
Has thanked: 5 times
Been thanked: 10 times

Post by BAGGIO 15 »

Hawkesy wrote:
BAGGIO 15 wrote:If this rule came in he wouldn't get into a lesser league in Europe as their best would be playing domesticly. If he did it would be good for him, but the A league and all ACL clubs would be even stronger.
He'd probably get a game at Fisher Athletic, so could play a similar standard but get more money.
:lol:
User avatar
delfino_1936
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 12847
Joined: Mon May 08, 2006 10:25 am

Post by delfino_1936 »

pires7 wrote:
Rigoni 10 wrote:
MUFCBOY wrote:
pires7 wrote:
MUFCBOY wrote:
pires7 wrote:the side is pretty much balanced! Business is still business, we dont want to buy a player for 10million to warm the bench! Any player we could buy this year won't get a game unless we bought them from another big 4 club!

Outide of this cant think of too many players in the league good enough to make our side!
i could think of atleast 5

gerrard, rooney, ronaldo, terry, cech, drogba.... thats 6, ill stop there
and i'm only talking englishmen
gerrard, terry, lampard, rooney, scholes, richards, rio
i'd only have richards, gerrard, terry, rooney, scholes
there is ZERO chance that Man U, Chelsea of Liverpool will sell us a player, unless they are finished! Name any other english players not at these clubs that could get a game!
Richards is one for the future but is cleary overated at the moment! Why in the world should we pay 20million for him when Toure and Gallas are better, more experienced players! and he wouldn't start in our back four anyways! He was found out big time v Chelsea, Drogba gave him a bath!
it's a hypathetical questions. i'm answering who i wouldn't mind having.
Image
User avatar
pires7
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 8994
Joined: Mon May 14, 2007 9:15 pm

Post by pires7 »

At the end of the say, Six Alex is a great manager but a knob at the same time!

there are 203 english players in the squads the 20 clubs this year!
so they are being given the chance to develop against the best players in the world! Fuck Australia barely has 200 professional players!

Blackburn with the least of 5 8)
Arsenal 6
Man City 7
Bolton 7
Pool 9
User avatar
cantona_united
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 143
Joined: Sat Jun 23, 2007 8:51 pm

Post by cantona_united »

pires7 wrote:At the end of the say, Six Alex is a great manager but a knob at the same time!

there are 203 english players in the squads the 20 clubs this year!
so they are being given the chance to develop against the best players in the world! shiraz Australia barely has 200 professional players!

Blackburn with the least of 5 8)
Arsenal 6
Man City 7
Bolton 7
Pool 9
only 1 (walcott) of those has really been given the chance to develop against the best players in the world.
User avatar
pires7
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 8994
Joined: Mon May 14, 2007 9:15 pm

Post by pires7 »

cantona_united wrote:
pires7 wrote:At the end of the say, Six Alex is a great manager but a knob at the same time!

there are 203 english players in the squads the 20 clubs this year!
so they are being given the chance to develop against the best players in the world! shiraz Australia barely has 200 professional players!

Blackburn with the least of 5 8)
Arsenal 6
Man City 7
Bolton 7
Pool 9
only 1 (walcott) of those has really been given the chance to develop against the best players in the world.
do you believe he is improving most from the 15 minute bursts he has been given to ease his way to first team football, or the training sessions with the squad? I'd like to think that some credit to training development is given?
It's a broken record now for the gunners, we have a new youth system and should begin to reap the home grown rewards in the next few years!
User avatar
cantona_united
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 143
Joined: Sat Jun 23, 2007 8:51 pm

Post by cantona_united »

pires7 wrote:
cantona_united wrote:
pires7 wrote:At the end of the say, Six Alex is a great manager but a knob at the same time!

there are 203 english players in the squads the 20 clubs this year!
so they are being given the chance to develop against the best players in the world! shiraz Australia barely has 200 professional players!

Blackburn with the least of 5 8)
Arsenal 6
Man City 7
Bolton 7
Pool 9
only 1 (walcott) of those has really been given the chance to develop against the best players in the world.
do you believe he is improving most from the 15 minute bursts he has been given to ease his way to first team football, or the training sessions with the squad? I'd like to think that some credit to training development is given?
It's a broken record now for the gunners, we have a new youth system and should begin to reap the home grown rewards in the next few years!
you didnt say that originally,you said they were improving by playing AGAINST the best players in the world, not from training. as for you're new youth system we'll have to wait and see wont we
User avatar
pires7
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 8994
Joined: Mon May 14, 2007 9:15 pm

Post by pires7 »

cantona_united wrote:
pires7 wrote:
cantona_united wrote:
pires7 wrote:At the end of the say, Six Alex is a great manager but a knob at the same time!

there are 203 english players in the squads the 20 clubs this year!
so they are being given the chance to develop against the best players in the world! shiraz Australia barely has 200 professional players!

Blackburn with the least of 5 8)
Arsenal 6
Man City 7
Bolton 7
Pool 9
only 1 (walcott) of those has really been given the chance to develop against the best players in the world.
do you believe he is improving most from the 15 minute bursts he has been given to ease his way to first team football, or the training sessions with the squad? I'd like to think that some credit to training development is given?
It's a broken record now for the gunners, we have a new youth system and should begin to reap the home grown rewards in the next few years!
you didnt say that originally,you said they were improving by playing AGAINST the best players in the world, not from training. as for you're new youth system we'll have to wait and see wont we
i didn't say playing against, i said develop, you simply implied that i meant playing!
Post Reply