One dayers

[Delete Your Account]

I thought this was a one dayer's thread.

Exactly.

Cook might be a great Test player, but he's definitely a reserve for their ODI squad.

[God is an Englishman]

I thought this was a one dayer's thread.

Exactly.

Cook might be a great Test player, but he's definitely a reserve for their ODI squad.

as are most of them playing. The squad for the west indies is apparently even worse - but I haven't seen that yet

[God is an Englishman]

Why would I listen to a biased aussie when I have my own eyes to tell me the truth. If it was as clear cut as you say then it wouldn't have taken the 3rd umpire over 3 minutes to make his decision.

The front on view was what nailed it. OUT!

Seen it, NOT OUT. Can you provide this conclusive picture you have mentioned.

[Bomber]

Why would I listen to a biased aussie when I have my own eyes to tell me the truth. If it was as clear cut as you say then it wouldn't have taken the 3rd umpire over 3 minutes to make his decision.

The front on view was what nailed it. OUT!

Seen it, NOT OUT. Can you provide this conclusive picture you have mentioned.

No, not a computer geek so wouldnt know how but I remember what I saw and obviously the third umpire did too.

Can you?

[God is an Englishman]

No, not a computer geek so wouldnt know how but I remember what I saw.

I think you're probably making the same mistake that the Channel 9 commentary team have made.

[Bomber]

No, not a computer geek so wouldnt know how but I remember what I saw.

I think you're probably making the same mistake that the Channel 9 commentary team have made.

Bail was dislodged, his foot was in the air, thats all I care about. Dont remember what commentary team was saying.

[God is an Englishman]

No, not a computer geek so wouldnt know how but I remember what I saw.

I think you're probably making the same mistake that the Channel 9 commentary team have made.

Bail was dislodged, his foot was in the air, thats all I care about. Dont remember what commentary team was saying.

Was the bail dislodged or removed from the stump completely. Remember both ends must be away from the stumps to be out - it wasn't, only one side was.

[predator]

Why would I listen to a biased aussie when I have my own eyes to tell me the truth. If it was as clear cut as you say then it wouldn't have taken the 3rd umpire over 3 minutes to make his decision.

The front on view was what nailed it. OUT!

Seen it, NOT OUT. Can you provide this conclusive picture you have mentioned.

Can you provide conclusive evidence that it wasn't out

[God is an Englishman]

Can you provide conclusive evidence that it wasn't out

watch the video, all the evidence you need. Not my fault you don't understand the laws

[Bomber]

No, not a computer geek so wouldnt know how but I remember what I saw.

I think you're probably making the same mistake that the Channel 9 commentary team have made.

Bail was dislodged, his foot was in the air, thats all I care about. Dont remember what commentary team was saying.

Was the bail dislodged or removed from the stump completely. Remember both ends must be away from the stumps to be out - it wasn't, only one side was.

Thats where you're mistaken. It was off both (before foot came down). OUT!

[God is an Englishman]

Thats where you're mistaken. It was off both (before foot came down). OUT!

disagree completely, as do MANY others (including australians)

[Bomber]

Agree to disagree then. Like I said, at first I thought same (not out) but after that particular front on angle was shown a few times, it was there, and obviously the third ump saw the same.

[God is an Englishman]

Agree to disagree then. Like I said, at first I thought same (not out) but after that particular front on angle was shown a few times, it was there, and obviously the third ump saw the same.

I think the bail was up at one end but not completely removed. I think if the situation was reversed then you'd be claiming he was not out.

On a side note, why don't umpires just make decisions any more. Every run out goes to the tv. 2 in England innings went to the TV and they were obvious to me on a dodgy angle and 50m away. Yet a bloke in line 10m away can't decide.

[Bomber]

On a side note, why don't umpires just make decisions any more. Every run out goes to the tv. 2 in England innings went to the TV and they were obvious to me on a dodgy angle and 50m away. Yet a bloke in line 10m away can't decide.

This part very true. The umps have got lazy since tv technology and find it easier to let the third guy make the call. Silly thing is the more they do it, the more they may one day just say we dont need them (the two in the middle) any more, thus losing their jobs!

[God is an Englishman]

On a side note, why don't umpires just make decisions any more. Every run out goes to the tv. 2 in England innings went to the TV and they were obvious to me on a dodgy angle and 50m away. Yet a bloke in line 10m away can't decide.

This part very true. The umps have got lazy since tv technology and find it easier to let the third guy make the call. Silly thing is the more they do it, the more they may one day just say we dont need them (the two in the middle) any more, thus losing their jobs!

Just have a hat stand with a camera in it, instead of umpires. Decision put up on the big screen for wides etc..

[Bomber]

On a side note, why don't umpires just make decisions any more. Every run out goes to the tv. 2 in England innings went to the TV and they were obvious to me on a dodgy angle and 50m away. Yet a bloke in line 10m away can't decide.

This part very true. The umps have got lazy since tv technology and find it easier to let the third guy make the call. Silly thing is the more they do it, the more they may one day just say we dont need them (the two in the middle) any more, thus losing their jobs!

Just have a hat stand with a camera in it, instead of umpires. Decision put up on the big screen for wides etc..

And a beep mechanism for no-balls much like in ten-pin bowling??

[predator]

watch the video

I have, 100% out

Not my fault you don't understand the laws

I'm still waiting for you to provide a link for your laws

[God is an Englishman]

watch the video

I have, 100% out

Not my fault you don't understand the laws

I'm still waiting for you to provide a link for your laws

wasn't it you who provided the link already? If not, check this thread out it has the link on it. the

[Bob Dobalina]

Post the link on this page.

[God is an Englishman]

Post the link on this page.

I don't do demands, but if you ask nicely then I will do so.

[Bob Dobalina]

So, you have NOTHING.

[God is an Englishman]

So, you have NOTHING.

I have the same as your manners then.

The link is in this thread, ask nicely and you can have it.

[Bob Dobalina]

My manners probably do need some work. As Mike Atherton said, when in Rome...

[God is an Englishman]

My manners probably do need some work. As Mike Atherton said, when in Rome...

Well said.

[Bomber]

Nice knock by Rohit yesterday, shattering the ODI international record with 264 runs off 173 balls only to get out on last ball of innings.

[Bomber]

Where's Jonny Lidon? Saffers spanked!

[Sotally Tober]

He stopped talking about cricket a long time ago.

[Jonny Lidon]

I'm here. Whats the problem? We'll beat you again next time too. So any idea who will win the toss for your captaincy? Seems like a lottery for Aussies these days.

[Bomber]

I'm here. Whats the problem? We'll beat you again next time too. So any idea who will win the toss for your captaincy? Seems like a lottery for Aussies these days.

2-1 up. You were wrong!

[Bomber]

3-1, series won. Any comments, Mr Lidon?