Official rules question
Moderators: BillShankly, John Cena, swannsong, Forum Admins
-
- Boot Polisher
- Posts: 59
- Joined: Sat May 14, 2011 5:47 pm
Official rules question
Ok, maybe im wrong because its a b grade game, but i was under the impression that kickoff is @1:10 and they play 45 minute halves. Whats the actual rules?
- Ernie Cooksey
- Star Player
- Posts: 3225
- Joined: Mon May 05, 2008 11:33 am
Re: Official rules question
Not of sure of exact rules but know if it starts late, the ref will cut it short so the first team game can start on time.
If it starts on time which I think is 1.10, I don't know why you'd need to shorten the halves.
If it starts on time which I think is 1.10, I don't know why you'd need to shorten the halves.
-
- Boot Polisher
- Posts: 59
- Joined: Sat May 14, 2011 5:47 pm
Re: Official rules question
The iggies club ref that did the c's and is currently doing the b's, told us at half time that the game is scheduled to start at 1:15 and in whatever circumstance its a 40 minute max half. He always tells players that he doesnt make the rules just enforces them, yet from what im watching he has no clue. Just yea.
Re: Official rules question
Blueblood's correct, it's 1:10pm and 45 minutes halves.some bloke wrote:The iggies club ref that did the c's and is currently doing the b's, told us at half time that the game is scheduled to start at 1:15 and in whatever circumstance its a 40 minute max half. He always tells players that he doesnt make the rules just enforces them, yet from what im watching he has no clue. Just yea.
-
- Club Captain
- Posts: 6686
- Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2007 5:25 pm
- Been thanked: 5 times
Re: Official rules question
Here's one from the jets-monarchs game. If the ref blows a whistle for a penalty and the team scores after the whistle, is he allowed to play advantage and give the scoring team a goal rather than award them a pen ?
Re: Official rules question
No, he's stopped the game by blowing the whistle beforehand...totsreds08 wrote:Here's one from the jets-monarchs game. If the ref blows a whistle for a penalty and the team scores after the whistle, is he allowed to play advantage and give the scoring team a goal rather than award them a pen ?
Re: Official rules question
No... Must go to the penalty... Unfortunate but law is the law!!totsreds08 wrote:Here's one from the jets-monarchs game. If the ref blows a whistle for a penalty and the team scores after the whistle, is he allowed to play advantage and give the scoring team a goal rather than award them a pen ?
Re: Official rules question
You sure? Ressies used to be 40 minutes I thought? C grade and A grade 45Chade wrote:Blueblood's correct, it's 1:10pm and 45 minutes halves.some bloke wrote:The iggies club ref that did the c's and is currently doing the b's, told us at half time that the game is scheduled to start at 1:15 and in whatever circumstance its a 40 minute max half. He always tells players that he doesnt make the rules just enforces them, yet from what im watching he has no clue. Just yea.
-
- Club Captain
- Posts: 6686
- Joined: Thu Jul 26, 2007 5:25 pm
- Been thanked: 5 times
Re: Official rules question
Well that happened against us. It was a joke decision. They probably would have scored but you never know.Chade wrote:No, he's stopped the game by blowing the whistle beforehand...totsreds08 wrote:Here's one from the jets-monarchs game. If the ref blows a whistle for a penalty and the team scores after the whistle, is he allowed to play advantage and give the scoring team a goal rather than award them a pen ?
Re: Official rules question
League Championship Rules Page: 13
24. DURATIO
OF THE MATCH
The duration of a match shall accord with the Laws of the Game save that Reserve and
Thirds championship matches if so directed by the League prior to the commencement of the
season may be reduced to two equal halves of 40 minutes each with an interval between the
halves not exceeding 10 minutes except by consent of the Referee.
Reserves and C teams play 40m halves. KO 1:10pm for reserves
24. DURATIO
OF THE MATCH
The duration of a match shall accord with the Laws of the Game save that Reserve and
Thirds championship matches if so directed by the League prior to the commencement of the
season may be reduced to two equal halves of 40 minutes each with an interval between the
halves not exceeding 10 minutes except by consent of the Referee.
Reserves and C teams play 40m halves. KO 1:10pm for reserves
- Stitch That
- Apprentice
- Posts: 186
- Joined: Tue Jul 26, 2011 11:14 pm
Re: Official rules question
That is in the SAASL rules but I have only seen two games where the referee has actually played 45 minutes in both halves.Chade wrote:Blueblood's correct, it's 1:10pm and 45 minutes halves.some bloke wrote:The iggies club ref that did the c's and is currently doing the b's, told us at half time that the game is scheduled to start at 1:15 and in whatever circumstance its a 40 minute max half. He always tells players that he doesnt make the rules just enforces them, yet from what im watching he has no clue. Just yea.
Possibly available in blue
Re: Official rules question
Pretty sure our home refs are playing 45 minute halves.
C grade is 40 minutes.BPBC wrote:You sure? Ressies used to be 40 minutes I thought? C grade and A grade 45Chade wrote:Blueblood's correct, it's 1:10pm and 45 minutes halves.some bloke wrote:The iggies club ref that did the c's and is currently doing the b's, told us at half time that the game is scheduled to start at 1:15 and in whatever circumstance its a 40 minute max half. He always tells players that he doesnt make the rules just enforces them, yet from what im watching he has no clue. Just yea.
- God is an Englishman
- Board Member
- Posts: 51452
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 5:31 pm
- Has thanked: 24 times
- Been thanked: 85 times
Re: Official rules question
totsreds08 wrote:Here's one from the jets-monarchs game. If the ref blows a whistle for a penalty and the team scores after the whistle, is he allowed to play advantage and give the scoring team a goal rather than award them a pen ?
I was in the shower at the time but I was told that the ref didn't blow the whistle until after the ball was in the net.
However, had it happened as you said then the ref should have gone back for the penalty. Happened for in the Millwall v leeds game last week and we missed the penalty.
- God is an Englishman
- Board Member
- Posts: 51452
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 5:31 pm
- Has thanked: 24 times
- Been thanked: 85 times
Re: Official rules question
Chade wrote:Blueblood's correct, it's 1:10pm and 45 minutes halves.some bloke wrote:The iggies club ref that did the c's and is currently doing the b's, told us at half time that the game is scheduled to start at 1:15 and in whatever circumstance its a 40 minute max half. He always tells players that he doesnt make the rules just enforces them, yet from what im watching he has no clue. Just yea.
I agree, the only anomily is that the game must end at 2:50pm.
Re: Official rules question
reserves k/o at 1:10 and play 45 minute halves from what i know, C's are 40 minute halves
CMON U SAINTS
There's only one le tissier
There's only one le tissier
- Jay Walking
- Team Manager
- Posts: 7408
- Joined: Tue Sep 05, 2006 8:13 pm
Re: Official rules question
C's Kick Off at 11:30am - 40 min halves
B's Kick Off at 1:10pm - 45 min halves
A's Kick Off at 3:00pm - 45 min halves
Its been this way for a while now.
Lol, sorry, typo
B's Kick Off at 1:10pm - 45 min halves
A's Kick Off at 3:00pm - 45 min halves
Its been this way for a while now.
Lol, sorry, typo
Re: Official rules question
+1Jay Slowly Running wrote:C's Kick Off at 11:30am - 40 min halves
B's Kick Off at 1:10pm - 45 min halves
A's Kick Off at 3:00pm - 45 min halves
Its been this way for a while now.
Lol, sorry, typo
Add 10 mins for half time and 10 mins between games, and the times line up perfectly.
- Clever Trevor
- Apprentice
- Posts: 214
- Joined: Sat Apr 21, 2012 7:24 pm
Re: Official rules question
Sunday div five. Barossa v Mantarays. Barossa throw-in. No touches. Barossa Goal. Referee counted it. :?
Re: Official rules question
Goal should not have stood. Ball needs to be touched before it crosses the line for the goal to count.Clever Trevor wrote:Sunday div five. Barossa v Mantarays. Barossa throw-in. No touches. Barossa Goal. Referee counted it. :?
How about this one... Penalty, keeper moved before the ball kicked, ball went in. Ref books keeper and orders taker to re take penalty. Shouldn't the goal have stood as after booking the keeper it was a disadvantage for the taker to have to re-take it. What would happen if the keeper saved it on the re-take.
'Winning doesn't really matter as long as you win.' - VINNY JONES
'It was like the ref had a brand new yellow card and wanted to see if it worked.' - RICHARD RUFUS
'It was like the ref had a brand new yellow card and wanted to see if it worked.' - RICHARD RUFUS
- God is an Englishman
- Board Member
- Posts: 51452
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 5:31 pm
- Has thanked: 24 times
- Been thanked: 85 times
Re: Official rules question
safehands wrote:Goal should not have stood. Ball needs to be touched before it crosses the line for the goal to count.Clever Trevor wrote:Sunday div five. Barossa v Mantarays. Barossa throw-in. No touches. Barossa Goal. Referee counted it. :?
How about this one... Penalty, keeper moved before the ball kicked, ball went in. Ref books keeper and orders taker to re take penalty. Shouldn't the goal have stood as after booking the keeper it was a disadvantage for the taker to have to re-take it. What would happen if the keeper saved it on the re-take.
Keeper can move before the ball is kicked, but he can't leave the line. If it goes in then GOAL!
Re: Official rules question
That was what I thought too...God is an Englishman wrote:safehands wrote:Goal should not have stood. Ball needs to be touched before it crosses the line for the goal to count.Clever Trevor wrote:Sunday div five. Barossa v Mantarays. Barossa throw-in. No touches. Barossa Goal. Referee counted it. :?
How about this one... Penalty, keeper moved before the ball kicked, ball went in. Ref books keeper and orders taker to re take penalty. Shouldn't the goal have stood as after booking the keeper it was a disadvantage for the taker to have to re-take it. What would happen if the keeper saved it on the re-take.
Keeper can move before the ball is kicked, but he can't leave the line. If it goes in then GOAL!
'Winning doesn't really matter as long as you win.' - VINNY JONES
'It was like the ref had a brand new yellow card and wanted to see if it worked.' - RICHARD RUFUS
'It was like the ref had a brand new yellow card and wanted to see if it worked.' - RICHARD RUFUS
- God is an Englishman
- Board Member
- Posts: 51452
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 5:31 pm
- Has thanked: 24 times
- Been thanked: 85 times
Re: Official rules question
safehands wrote:That was what I thought too...
are you sure it wasn't for the attacking team encroaching into the box.
Re: Official rules question
what would be the decision in this situation-
attacking player slips the ball past out coming keeper who cant recover, attacking player realises the ball is going wide of the goal,with a defender chasing him down he manages to keep the ball in play but both him and the defender leave the field of play in their pursuit and before the attacking player is about to run back on the the field and tap the ball into an empty net the defending player fouls him before he re-enters the field of play.
what would the ref give as the foul is not committed in the penalty box?
attacking player slips the ball past out coming keeper who cant recover, attacking player realises the ball is going wide of the goal,with a defender chasing him down he manages to keep the ball in play but both him and the defender leave the field of play in their pursuit and before the attacking player is about to run back on the the field and tap the ball into an empty net the defending player fouls him before he re-enters the field of play.
what would the ref give as the foul is not committed in the penalty box?
Re: Official rules question
Penalty... Spirit of the game... Common sense..keegan wrote:what would be the decision in this situation-
attacking player slips the ball past out coming keeper who cant recover, attacking player realises the ball is going wide of the goal,with a defender chasing him down he manages to keep the ball in play but both him and the defender leave the field of play in their pursuit and before the attacking player is about to run back on the the field and tap the ball into an empty net the defending player fouls him before he re-enters the field of play.
what would the ref give as the foul is not committed in the penalty box?
- God is an Englishman
- Board Member
- Posts: 51452
- Joined: Fri May 08, 2009 5:31 pm
- Has thanked: 24 times
- Been thanked: 85 times
Re: Official rules question
keegan wrote:what would be the decision in this situation-
attacking player slips the ball past out coming keeper who cant recover, attacking player realises the ball is going wide of the goal,with a defender chasing him down he manages to keep the ball in play but both him and the defender leave the field of play in their pursuit and before the attacking player is about to run back on the the field and tap the ball into an empty net the defending player fouls him before he re-enters the field of play.
what would the ref give as the foul is not committed in the penalty box?
GOOD ONE!
I would say that you can't give a penalty etc as the foul has not been committed inside the box, you cannot send off the defender because it's an offence not punishable by a DFK. You could still book the player (red if serious enough) but it's play on. If you need to stop the game then it would be a drop ball wherever the ball was when the whistle was blown.
However, would love to hear what a higher qualified ref has to say.
- Βόρειας Κύπρου
- Apprentice
- Posts: 248
- Joined: Tue Aug 18, 2009 2:03 pm
Re: Official rules question
No, you need to stop play to book a player if play is not already stopped.God is an Englishman wrote:You could still book the player (red if serious enough) but it's play on.
Unless the referee stops the play to book a player, in which it is an indirect free kick to the opposing team.God is an Englishman wrote: If you need to stop the game then it would be a drop ball wherever the ball was when the whistle was blown.
aftos pou pidai pola paloukia tha tou hothi kai ena sto kolo
Re: Official rules question
If a player is outside the pitch (in such a case where they are chasing the ball/player), then they are deemed to effectively be on the pitch at the nearest point (so a straight line to the pitch). This is the same if a player leaves the pitch, they are deemed to be on the line when it comes to offside. It would be a penalty, as the foul would (effectively) be occuring on the goal line.
On the weekend there was a penalty, and a couple of Parafield Gardens players tried to stand next to the goal posts but off the pitch. This is not allowed, as they are deemed to be "on the pitch" inside the penalty area.
On the weekend there was a penalty, and a couple of Parafield Gardens players tried to stand next to the goal posts but off the pitch. This is not allowed, as they are deemed to be "on the pitch" inside the penalty area.
-
- Bench Warmer
- Posts: 968
- Joined: Mon Aug 09, 2010 10:31 am
Re: Official rules question
[On the weekend there was a penalty, and a couple of Parafield Gardens players tried to stand next to the goal posts but off the pitch. This is not allowed, as they are deemed to be "on the pitch" inside the penalty area.[/quote]
Should have both been booked for leaving the playing field without the referees permission.
Should have both been booked for leaving the playing field without the referees permission.
Re: Official rules question
pernunz wrote: On the weekend there was a penalty, and a couple of Parafield Gardens players tried to stand next to the goal posts but off the pitch. This is not allowed, as they are deemed to be "on the pitch" inside the penalty area.
I'm always amazed at the crap some people pull to get around the rules. Thankfully the lawmakers put "unsportsmanlike behaviour" in the laws as a cautionable offence, which gives the referee a lot of leeway to clamp down on things like that.