CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

This forum is for the discussion of amateur league football.

Moderators: BillShankly, John Cena, swannsong, Forum Admins

Ga Pala
Star Player
Star Player
Posts: 2633
Joined: Mon Aug 14, 2006 6:58 pm
Been thanked: 5 times

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Ga Pala »

You know what they say when u assume Knight15 . I'm involved in the Amateur league FYI .
" I used to go Missing a lot- Miss Canada, Miss United Kingdom, Miss Germany." George Best
Knight15
First Team Regular
First Team Regular
Posts: 1846
Joined: Fri May 06, 2011 10:19 am

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Knight15 »

Ga Pala wrote:You know what they say when u assume Knight15 . I'm involved in the Amateur league FYI .
And your point is?

Your attitude is typical of the problems associated with the Federation
Are you Bodo in disguise?
User avatar
Željko Jurin
Team Manager
Team Manager
Posts: 9625
Joined: Fri Mar 02, 2007 2:25 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Željko Jurin »

lefty wrote:
Željko Jurin wrote:
bigpond wrote: Clubs like Downs, Mod Vista, Gardens and Fulham have the facilities if they wanted to go over.
No offence to those clubs, but a waste of time really to ask them as there are already alot of Feb clubs in those areas .......
So where would they come from western & eastern suburbs thought there would be enough in those areas already too, wont be south they are struggling as it is, perhaps the country like Pt Pirie :roll:

Go & do some home work ZJ & you will find that the north is the growth area in terms of demographics & FFSA know it. Perhaps your frightened of competition now that your club is in the north.
I wouldn't get any, there is too many already ....

Why would I be frightened, isn't E&D the biggest junior comp in ADL, and we are very close by
Spot Željko Jurin Jnr ......

Image
BlackBrian_7
Squad Player
Squad Player
Posts: 1599
Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2011 1:25 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by BlackBrian_7 »

lisbon lion wrote:
BlackBrian_7 wrote:
Trimboli wrote:Sounds like Banya and ORB present some pretty sound arguments - hard to argue against. Amateur sides are happy being amateur sides and don't want to go to Feds rather boring party answer have better fun enjoying their own. Justbecause people get invited does not place them under any obligation and nor should it.
If they are happy being amateur why then do they feel it necessary to pay players?

Look for the cost of being in the feds I don't see the value either.
obviously you have no idea how things work :shock:
I appreciate that is how things work, however everyone is jumping up and down about wanting to just be social and 'amateur' clubs yet they boast about shelling out tens of thousands of dollars in player payments.

Just seems illogical and hypocritical.
User avatar
swannsong
Technical Director
Technical Director
Posts: 30004
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2007 10:15 pm
Been thanked: 3 times

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by swannsong »

BlackBrian_7 wrote:
I appreciate that is how things work, however everyone is jumping up and down about wanting to just be social and 'amateur' clubs yet they boast about shelling out tens of thousands of dollars in player payments.

Just seems illogical and hypocritical.
I don't recall any clubs bragging about paying players, most of that noise comes from the likes of yourself and people from opposition clubs.
The only "bragging" per se, is about spectators, club stability etc...
Image
Southern Knights SC - 2024 - Celebrating 30 Years of SAASL Football
SAASL facebook : Southern Knights SC facebook
swannsong Facebook : Elizabeth Downs SC facebook
User avatar
KING NUGGETT
Star Player
Star Player
Posts: 2482
Joined: Mon May 17, 2010 2:36 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by KING NUGGETT »

BlackBrian_7 wrote:
I appreciate that is how things work, however everyone is jumping up and down about wanting to just be social and 'amateur' clubs yet they boast about shelling out tens of thousands of dollars in player payments.

Just seems illogical and hypocritical.
Sorry BlackBrian_7 but you obviously have No Understanding about it. To say Clubs in the SAASL just want to be social obviously you havent been to a Div.1 SUNDAY game lately! Yes were all Proud & very happy to play in the SAASL PREMIER LEAGUE but it so far from a social kick around. It is for sheep stations for us Div.1 Clubs as I'm sure a Div.2 or 3 Title is to the Clubs that win them!
And No we aren't bragging & bringing up about paying Tens of Thousands of Dollars You Are!!!

SAASL DIV.1 CHAMPIONS 73,75,78,02,10,11,13
CHALLENGE CUP WINNERS 74,75,80,08,10,11,13
SAASL DIV.1 RES. CHAMPIONS 71,75,77,78,79,94,11,13
RES. CUP WINNERS 73,75,76,13
CHAMPIONS OF CHAMPIONS 10
CICHANOWSKI SHIELD 90,08,11,12,14

Est.1966
User avatar
Bomber
Vice Chairman
Vice Chairman
Posts: 60529
Joined: Tue Apr 04, 2006 11:40 am
Has thanked: 46 times
Been thanked: 141 times

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Bomber »

BlackBrian_7 wrote:
Bomber wrote:
Paleon Patros Germanos wrote:Pretty touchy on the subject Ga Pala?

Happy to be corrected but at the moment the Downs and Gardens of the world are happy with the competition they are in, they are happy with their junior set-ups and given the costs and the standard they initially will face in the Feds, wish to stay put.

On the other hand, clubs like yours, may harbour further ambition and wish to move to the Feds. Thats great but be warned for every Comets and Metro, there is an NAB and Toros.
Well said. I dont know of too many amateur sides unhappy with their status at the moment. If it aint broke, why try fix it? Like I said, if they dont get more teams in for 2013 (Feds), then more egg on their face! Tried to tell them to stick with two divisions, slightly bigger leagues, but "the majority" seem to know best.
Bomber, the big problem with the 2 leagues is that there really is a massive drop off from top half of the second div to the bottom.

The way it is now keeps the standard more even amongst the teams, no-one really wants to see Seaford go through another 57 game or so winless streak do they?
No, but playing Gawler and Cove (no offence to these teams) week in week out is hardly likely to improve things at Seaford is it! Sink or swim. We are trying to improve football in SA yet there is this mentality that less teams in smaller leagues is more comfortable and somehow "better" - yes "better" for the weaker teams, so they dont want to spoil it!
Until people start seeing the big picture, mediocrity will always be accepted and prevail in this state.
Ignore this signature
BlackBrian_7
Squad Player
Squad Player
Posts: 1599
Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2011 1:25 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by BlackBrian_7 »

Ok I retract my point about bragging as the clubs involved generally don't do that. However it is a widely held belief that some clubs in particular have rather heavy player payment outgoings.

A lot of people on here talk about player xx being at their club because of the social atmosphere and don't enjoy the seriousness of fed football. If you are a winner don't you want to pit yourself against the best?
Ga Pala
Star Player
Star Player
Posts: 2633
Joined: Mon Aug 14, 2006 6:58 pm
Been thanked: 5 times

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Ga Pala »

Black Brian Didn't you know that players want to play at Clubs like Downs And Gardens for the fantastic environment
And fantastic surrounds not the money? Yeah right :lol:
" I used to go Missing a lot- Miss Canada, Miss United Kingdom, Miss Germany." George Best
BlackBrian_7
Squad Player
Squad Player
Posts: 1599
Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2011 1:25 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by BlackBrian_7 »

Bomber wrote:
BlackBrian_7 wrote: Bomber, the big problem with the 2 leagues is that there really is a massive drop off from top half of the second div to the bottom.

The way it is now keeps the standard more even amongst the teams, no-one really wants to see Seaford go through another 57 game or so winless streak do they?
No, but playing Gawler and Cove (no offence to these teams) week in week out is hardly likely to improve things at Seaford is it! Sink or swim. We are trying to improve football in SA yet there is this mentality that less teams in smaller leagues is more comfortable and somehow "better" - yes "better" for the weaker teams, so they dont want to spoil it!
Until people start seeing the big picture, mediocrity will always be accepted and prevail in this state.
In an ideal world there would be promotion relegation to amateur leagues from the bottom semi-pro division, however due to the mismanagement of the governing body here this won't happen in the foreseeable future.

The serious clubs do play in competitive divisions (super & premier league) with the development/regional type clubs playing in the state league. I don't think there is any value in a team like Croydon playing teams like Seaford, Cove, Gawler, Northern Demons on a regular basis as it will bring your standard down - yet it is important for these clubs to exist as they are in huge areas of potential growth and there is a need for them to exist.
User avatar
Bomber
Vice Chairman
Vice Chairman
Posts: 60529
Joined: Tue Apr 04, 2006 11:40 am
Has thanked: 46 times
Been thanked: 141 times

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Bomber »

BlackBrian_7 wrote:
Bomber wrote:
BlackBrian_7 wrote: Bomber, the big problem with the 2 leagues is that there really is a massive drop off from top half of the second div to the bottom.

The way it is now keeps the standard more even amongst the teams, no-one really wants to see Seaford go through another 57 game or so winless streak do they?
No, but playing Gawler and Cove (no offence to these teams) week in week out is hardly likely to improve things at Seaford is it! Sink or swim. We are trying to improve football in SA yet there is this mentality that less teams in smaller leagues is more comfortable and somehow "better" - yes "better" for the weaker teams, so they dont want to spoil it!
Until people start seeing the big picture, mediocrity will always be accepted and prevail in this state.
In an ideal world there would be promotion relegation to amateur leagues from the bottom semi-pro division, however due to the mismanagement of the governing body here this won't happen in the foreseeable future.

The serious clubs do play in competitive divisions (super & premier league) with the development/regional type clubs playing in the state league. I don't think there is any value in a team like Croydon playing teams like Seaford, Cove, Gawler, Northern Demons on a regular basis as it will bring your standard down - yet it is important for these clubs to exist as they are in huge areas of potential growth and there is a need for them to exist.

.....and whilst the status quo remains, so will the gap. Big picture, my friend, big picture. It will take a few years, but it will even out over time. At the moment, consider the interim period - if you are going to use Croydon as an example (not sure why as we are in the Super league, not Premier League) and we had to play a weaker side, it gives our coach an opportunity to be more flexible in who he plays in that fixture (ie maybe a couple of 15 or 16 year olds could get more games). In a longer season, more flexibility can be looked at. In a short 18 game season, even a minor injury can result in a player missing a third of the season. it benefits very few.
Ignore this signature
User avatar
BANYA
Bench Warmer
Bench Warmer
Posts: 635
Joined: Wed May 30, 2007 2:26 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by BANYA »

Ga Pala wrote:Black Brian Didn't you know that players want to play at Clubs like Downs And Gardens for the fantastic environment
And fantastic surrounds not the money? Yeah right :lol:
I do!!! Have you ever spoken to a Downs or Gardens player and asked them why they play there? Most are there because they played Juniors or have family or close friends there. Got naff all to do with $$$. I played 7 years juniors for the Downs, 3 For Salisbury & then 4 years @ SASI. I then played for both Playford & Modbury Seniors (and won a Federation Cup with Playford) and then went to the Downs as a 19yr Old... Why, playing juniors for them helped but because the culture @ Fed Level is non existent, people are plastic and they only like you for what you can do, not who you are. i was so disenchanted by the system that i was ready to give up. Ask yourself why are the two Lindsay boys @ The Downs this yr??? As if they wouldn't walk into a Super League team. Now @ The Downs, where I wouldn't rather spend my weekends playing/supporting anywhere else... My family are welcomed, we are all friends, and now my children are growing up in a fantastic, supportive, family orientated environment. Gay Pala & Bwack Bwian you have no idea, you stick to sipping latte's on the Parade & ill slam back a Pale Ale @ Argy...
WHY DO THEY CALL IT OVALTINE? I MEAN ITS ROUND, WHY DONT THEY CALL IT ROUNDTINE.
User avatar
Rodent
Squad Player
Squad Player
Posts: 1415
Joined: Wed Jan 14, 2009 5:08 pm
Has thanked: 1 time

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Rodent »

BANYA wrote:
Ga Pala wrote:Black Brian Didn't you know that players want to play at Clubs like Downs And Gardens for the fantastic environment
And fantastic surrounds not the money? Yeah right :lol:
I do!!! Have you ever spoken to a Downs or Gardens player and asked them why they play there? Most are there because they played Juniors or have family or close friends there. Got naff all to do with $$$. I played 7 years juniors for the Downs, 3 For Salisbury & then 4 years @ SASI. I then played for both Playford & Modbury Seniors (and won a Federation Cup with Playford) and then went to the Downs as a 19yr Old... Why, playing juniors for them helped but because the culture @ Fed Level is non existent, people are plastic and they only like you for what you can do, not who you are. i was so disenchanted by the system that i was ready to give up. Ask yourself why are the two Lindsay boys @ The Downs this yr??? As if they wouldn't walk into a Super League team. Now @ The Downs, where I wouldn't rather spend my weekends playing/supporting anywhere else... My family are welcomed, we are all friends, and now my children are growing up in a fantastic, supportive, family orientated environment. Gay Pala & Bwack Bwian you have no idea, you stick to sipping latte's on the Parade & ill slam back a Pale Ale @ Argy...

100% correct and unless you.. have been to, played for, or grown up at clubs like downs gardens vale ingle farm you will never understand....all you will do is assume that they are only there for the money....!!
Every Rat has his day !!
User avatar
KING NUGGETT
Star Player
Star Player
Posts: 2482
Joined: Mon May 17, 2010 2:36 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by KING NUGGETT »

Sippin latte at the parade??? More like lube'n up at the Torrens !!!!

SAASL DIV.1 CHAMPIONS 73,75,78,02,10,11,13
CHALLENGE CUP WINNERS 74,75,80,08,10,11,13
SAASL DIV.1 RES. CHAMPIONS 71,75,77,78,79,94,11,13
RES. CUP WINNERS 73,75,76,13
CHAMPIONS OF CHAMPIONS 10
CICHANOWSKI SHIELD 90,08,11,12,14

Est.1966
BlackBrian_7
Squad Player
Squad Player
Posts: 1599
Joined: Thu Feb 24, 2011 1:25 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by BlackBrian_7 »

KING NUGGETT wrote:Sippin latte at the parade??? More like lube'n up at the Torrens !!!!
You get pretty excited about that sort of stuff don't you nugget?
User avatar
bapa
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 17837
Joined: Thu Nov 26, 2009 11:08 am

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by bapa »

BlackBrian_7 wrote:
KING NUGGETT wrote:Sippin latte at the parade??? More like lube'n up at the Torrens !!!!
You get pretty excited about that sort of stuff don't you nugget?

:lol: :lol: :lol:
User avatar
BANYA
Bench Warmer
Bench Warmer
Posts: 635
Joined: Wed May 30, 2007 2:26 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by BANYA »

KING NUGGETT wrote:Sippin latte at the parade??? More like lube'n up at the Torrens !!!!
:D :D :D
WHY DO THEY CALL IT OVALTINE? I MEAN ITS ROUND, WHY DONT THEY CALL IT ROUNDTINE.
Soap Box
Apprentice
Apprentice
Posts: 184
Joined: Tue Jun 09, 2009 1:39 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Soap Box »

BANYA wrote:
Ga Pala wrote:Black Brian Didn't you know that players want to play at Clubs like Downs And Gardens for the fantastic environment
And fantastic surrounds not the money? Yeah right :lol:
I do!!! Have you ever spoken to a Downs or Gardens player and asked them why they play there? Most are there because they played Juniors or have family or close friends there. Got naff all to do with $$$. I played 7 years juniors for the Downs, 3 For Salisbury & then 4 years @ SASI. I then played for both Playford & Modbury Seniors (and won a Federation Cup with Playford) and then went to the Downs as a 19yr Old... Why, playing juniors for them helped but because the culture @ Fed Level is non existent, people are plastic and they only like you for what you can do, not who you are. i was so disenchanted by the system that i was ready to give up. Ask yourself why are the two Lindsay boys @ The Downs this yr??? As if they wouldn't walk into a Super League team. Now @ The Downs, where I wouldn't rather spend my weekends playing/supporting anywhere else... My family are welcomed, we are all friends, and now my children are growing up in a fantastic, supportive, family orientated environment. Gay Pala & Bwack Bwian you have no idea, you stick to sipping latte's on the Parade & ill slam back a Pale Ale @ Argy...

sounds like its worked out for you and good luck to you. May be you had a bad experience yourself but a bit rough to say people are plastic in fed clubs. Club loyalty is a part of the reason players return to there roots your fooling yourself if you dont think money has a big part to play as well. Those players would not be there if money wasnt part of the deal and which super leage club first team would your players walk into you think?
User avatar
bapa
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 17837
Joined: Thu Nov 26, 2009 11:08 am

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by bapa »

Soap Box wrote:
BANYA wrote:
Ga Pala wrote:Black Brian Didn't you know that players want to play at Clubs like Downs And Gardens for the fantastic environment
And fantastic surrounds not the money? Yeah right :lol:
I do!!! Have you ever spoken to a Downs or Gardens player and asked them why they play there? Most are there because they played Juniors or have family or close friends there. Got naff all to do with $$$. I played 7 years juniors for the Downs, 3 For Salisbury & then 4 years @ SASI. I then played for both Playford & Modbury Seniors (and won a Federation Cup with Playford) and then went to the Downs as a 19yr Old... Why, playing juniors for them helped but because the culture @ Fed Level is non existent, people are plastic and they only like you for what you can do, not who you are. i was so disenchanted by the system that i was ready to give up. Ask yourself why are the two Lindsay boys @ The Downs this yr??? As if they wouldn't walk into a Super League team. Now @ The Downs, where I wouldn't rather spend my weekends playing/supporting anywhere else... My family are welcomed, we are all friends, and now my children are growing up in a fantastic, supportive, family orientated environment. Gay Pala & Bwack Bwian you have no idea, you stick to sipping latte's on the Parade & ill slam back a Pale Ale @ Argy...

sounds like its worked out for you and good luck to you. May be you had a bad experience yourself but a bit rough to say people are plastic in fed clubs. Club loyalty is a part of the reason players return to there roots your fooling yourself if you dont think money has a big part to play as well. Those players would not be there if money wasnt part of the deal and which super leage club first team would your players walk into you think?

it happens at every club withna bit of cash
money talhks and bullsh*t walks.

i have no problem with clubs offering $$$ to players, good on them - to the players that is!
as for environments in the clubs mentioned above, i thoroughly enjoyed playing at Gardens, downs, vale, ingle farms ec. some of the characters and one liners are awesomely funny.
not to mention the supporters and the volunteers those clubs get - kudos to them!
if they can generate fantastoic support at games which leads to bar and food taking, so be it.
they can afford to play players a bit of coin. it adds to a better game being played.

can u imagine all the teams and players if their was no money given to players???


go watch over 35's, the quality is still there but the skill level is not...
User avatar
Lucas Leiva
First Team Regular
First Team Regular
Posts: 2130
Joined: Mon Apr 03, 2006 10:32 am

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Lucas Leiva »

Rodent wrote:
BANYA wrote:
Ga Pala wrote:Black Brian Didn't you know that players want to play at Clubs like Downs And Gardens for the fantastic environment
And fantastic surrounds not the money? Yeah right :lol:
I do!!! Have you ever spoken to a Downs or Gardens player and asked them why they play there? Most are there because they played Juniors or have family or close friends there. Got naff all to do with $$$. I played 7 years juniors for the Downs, 3 For Salisbury & then 4 years @ SASI. I then played for both Playford & Modbury Seniors (and won a Federation Cup with Playford) and then went to the Downs as a 19yr Old... Why, playing juniors for them helped but because the culture @ Fed Level is non existent, people are plastic and they only like you for what you can do, not who you are. i was so disenchanted by the system that i was ready to give up. Ask yourself why are the two Lindsay boys @ The Downs this yr??? As if they wouldn't walk into a Super League team. Now @ The Downs, where I wouldn't rather spend my weekends playing/supporting anywhere else... My family are welcomed, we are all friends, and now my children are growing up in a fantastic, supportive, family orientated environment. Gay Pala & Bwack Bwian you have no idea, you stick to sipping latte's on the Parade & ill slam back a Pale Ale @ Argy...

100% correct and unless you.. have been to, played for, or grown up at clubs like downs gardens vale ingle farm you will never understand....all you will do is assume that they are only there for the money....!!
I think this comment goes hand in hand with some of the opinion on this post. Just because you've not played at Downs, Gardens, etc. doesn't mean you've not played at a great club with a great cultural or community environment.

I played for a club for 17 years from the age of 8 in the Feds, and let me tell you it was a great environment as a kid / teen - playing and watching the Seniors. Families and spectators that I used to watch Seniors with then watched me as I climbed the ranks. As I got older and my ability prevented me from going further, I started to play Amateurs. Whilst not having any near as many people at the club I've been involved in, there is still a real sense of community and I've played with as much passion for my current amateur club Vipers FC of 5 years as I did for my fed club of 17 years.

We've been around for 5 years and we have great derby matches against the likes of Comets and Salisbury Villa and I love that, but it's no less important or passionate because we've not got the same history or facilities or amount of former feds earning "no more than $99". To me and my club and our opposition, Vipers vs. Comets is just as big as Gardens vs. Downs.

So, in other words - I totally understand what Banya says with wanting to be involved at a club with a community, but I also appreciate what Black Brian says in the perception of other clubs.

You perceive some clubs as lacking community (which may or may not be the case), whereas others perceive your club of paying blokes who can't be bothered training 3 times a week in Feds (which may or may not be the case).
4-4-2
Promising Junior
Promising Junior
Posts: 310
Joined: Wed Jul 09, 2008 12:28 am

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by 4-4-2 »

The reality of it all is they need us but we don't need them. People like to talk about mercenaries etc playing in amateurs but all the fed clubs were willing to pay them the big dollars in they hey day. Im sure that metro splashed the cash to get where they are today but is their model more sustainable then that of the big amateur clubs? I don't think so personally. They offer free entry and still get stuff all through the gates, what happens when the few people who put big money into the club loose interest? Raiders are an example of a team who played big dollars to get players such as morrison, cerrachio, cambell, trimboli etc. These players have now come into the amateur system and we are stronger for it. Raiders also run a more sustainable model now and look where they now sit in the league. Clubs pay what they can afford and if you have it then do it. Over the years edjsa have produced plenty of players for fed clubs and amateur clubs have provided a good outlet for players who might not be able to make that next step at fed level or just want a lesser commitment to training. Having the chance to play alongside players such as cambell, grenache, jones, ennis etc has been a great experience as well as playing against players like karepitis, day, elbows morrison :-) , ivanovic, saraceno, stam - the list could go on. I can't recall any top amateur clubs looking to make a break away league unlike the fed clubs recently. Personally I think they should make a break away league cos you are in a league run by a bunch of idiots. If your not happy with the way things are blame the idiots who changed reserves to u23's cos that really screwed you all over and get rid of the current tosser in charge as he has no idea on how best to approach the subject of unifying football in this state, after all baseball has gone from strength to strength since his departure
Paleon Patros Germanos
Star Player
Star Player
Posts: 4238
Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 3:35 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Paleon Patros Germanos »

Lucas Leiva wrote: I think this comment goes hand in hand with some of the opinion on this post. Just because you've not played at Downs, Gardens, etc. doesn't mean you've not played at a great club with a great cultural or community environment.

I played for a club for 17 years from the age of 8 in the Feds, and let me tell you it was a great environment as a kid / teen - playing and watching the Seniors. Families and spectators that I used to watch Seniors with then watched me as I climbed the ranks. As I got older and my ability prevented me from going further, I started to play Amateurs. Whilst not having any near as many people at the club I've been involved in, there is still a real sense of community and I've played with as much passion for my current amateur club Vipers FC of 5 years as I did for my fed club of 17 years.

We've been around for 5 years and we have great derby matches against the likes of Comets and Salisbury Villa and I love that, but it's no less important or passionate because we've not got the same history or facilities or amount of former feds earning "no more than $99". To me and my club and our opposition, Vipers vs. Comets is just as big as Gardens vs. Downs.

So, in other words - I totally understand what Banya says with wanting to be involved at a club with a community, but I also appreciate what Black Brian says in the perception of other clubs.

You perceive some clubs as lacking community (which may or may not be the case), whereas others perceive your club of paying blokes who can't be bothered training 3 times a week in Feds (which may or may not be the case).
And F@cking how you used to give me the shits for those 17 years.
:lol: :lol: :lol:
Agia Lavra 1821!
User avatar
Lucas Leiva
First Team Regular
First Team Regular
Posts: 2130
Joined: Mon Apr 03, 2006 10:32 am

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Lucas Leiva »

Paleon Patros Germanos wrote:
Lucas Leiva wrote: I think this comment goes hand in hand with some of the opinion on this post. Just because you've not played at Downs, Gardens, etc. doesn't mean you've not played at a great club with a great cultural or community environment.

I played for a club for 17 years from the age of 8 in the Feds, and let me tell you it was a great environment as a kid / teen - playing and watching the Seniors. Families and spectators that I used to watch Seniors with then watched me as I climbed the ranks. As I got older and my ability prevented me from going further, I started to play Amateurs. Whilst not having any near as many people at the club I've been involved in, there is still a real sense of community and I've played with as much passion for my current amateur club Vipers FC of 5 years as I did for my fed club of 17 years.

We've been around for 5 years and we have great derby matches against the likes of Comets and Salisbury Villa and I love that, but it's no less important or passionate because we've not got the same history or facilities or amount of former feds earning "no more than $99". To me and my club and our opposition, Vipers vs. Comets is just as big as Gardens vs. Downs.

So, in other words - I totally understand what Banya says with wanting to be involved at a club with a community, but I also appreciate what Black Brian says in the perception of other clubs.

You perceive some clubs as lacking community (which may or may not be the case), whereas others perceive your club of paying blokes who can't be bothered training 3 times a week in Feds (which may or may not be the case).
And F@shiraz how you used to give me the shits for those 17 years.
:lol: :lol: :lol:
Don't worry, I counted every ball you booted into your backyard :lol:
User avatar
Porky
Squad Player
Squad Player
Posts: 1385
Joined: Mon Aug 29, 2011 5:56 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by Porky »

Soap Box wrote:
sounds like its worked out for you and good luck to you. May be you had a bad experience yourself but a bit rough to say people are plastic in fed clubs. Club loyalty is a part of the reason players return to there roots your fooling yourself if you dont think money has a big part to play as well. Those players would not be there if money wasnt part of the deal and which super leage club first team would your players walk into you think?
In SAASL the money is just a bonus mate...and the majority of any money gained normally goes back into the club after trainings, games etc you people have no idea
magicfootball1
Promising Junior
Promising Junior
Posts: 260
Joined: Sat Mar 05, 2011 11:29 am

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by magicfootball1 »

BANYA wrote:
Ga Pala wrote:Black Brian Didn't you know that players want to play at Clubs like Downs And Gardens for the fantastic environment
And fantastic surrounds not the money? Yeah right :lol:
I do!!! Have you ever spoken to a Downs or Gardens player and asked them why they play there? Most are there because they played Juniors or have family or close friends there. Got naff all to do with $$$. I played 7 years juniors for the Downs, 3 For Salisbury & then 4 years @ SASI. I then played for both Playford & Modbury Seniors (and won a Federation Cup with Playford) and then went to the Downs as a 19yr Old... Why, playing juniors for them helped but because the culture @ Fed Level is non existent, people are plastic and they only like you for what you can do, not who you are. i was so disenchanted by the system that i was ready to give up. Ask yourself why are the two Lindsay boys @ The Downs this yr??? As if they wouldn't walk into a Super League team. Now @ The Downs, where I wouldn't rather spend my weekends playing/supporting anywhere else... My family are welcomed, we are all friends, and now my children are growing up in a fantastic, supportive, family orientated environment. Gay Pala & Bwack Bwian you have no idea, you stick to sipping latte's on the Parade & ill slam back a Pale Ale @ Argy...

uhmmm well funny you should mention Lindsay boys; the fact, they are related to the coach would be the real reason. The fact, the pressure mounted on a lindsay to leave a winning club would be the real reason ? The fact the coach has made a big who-ha about winning this year, you talk so much BS.
The main issue as Bomber puts it, is the big picture whether we play amatuer or fed we all play the same game and should be working together not against each other.

i do agree with you "Why, playing juniors for them helped but because the culture @ Fed Level is non existent, people are plastic and they only like you for what you can do, not who you are"
adelaidepie
Promising Junior
Promising Junior
Posts: 359
Joined: Thu Jan 03, 2008 8:47 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by adelaidepie »

Not sure if this has been said before but if the FFSA And the SAAFL made up they cold look at a promotion relegation via state league and Saturday Sunday div 1? Bitlike the Conference league and League two.

As long as the fees weren't high and you could get teams and officials to agree it could colve the $$ to go up but also help combine the two associations.

Just a thought
Notts County Football Club the oldest and still the best. Black and White magic

NOTTS COUNTY CHAMPIONS DIVISION 2 2010
User avatar
DOC
Assistant Coach
Assistant Coach
Posts: 12834
Joined: Wed Sep 06, 2006 1:37 am

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by DOC »

this would require the two factions to be on speaking terms :lol:
ImageImage
jackdogs
Boot Polisher
Boot Polisher
Posts: 96
Joined: Sat Jun 04, 2011 5:22 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by jackdogs »

why why why would any one bother entering into this discussion with the feds,

they are so jealous of what we have in the amateur league, that is why this topic was put to newspaper reporters and that is why they rang around to certain clubs.

A few good points have been made First and foremost is the EDJSA comp abosolutely is the best run junior comp in the state, once upon a time we had a state junior carnival now all clubs affliated with the FFSA have been banned from participating in any competions with E&D clubs. I have requested a trial game with a local Fed club only to be told they are not permitted to play E&D clubs.

Secondly always the issue of paying players, I see such payments and gratuity for services provided and nothing more. The price clubs pay depending on the quality of service is up to them and the player. I agree that most of the payments end up back over the bar any way so its a win win for all. If your supporters enjoy watching better players play for their club then the better players will and should be rewarded.

Final can anyone remember the SAFA in the aussie rules a while ago, a breakaway competition organised by successful ego driven amateur clubs of the day with the backing of the SANFL only to be dead in the water within 4 years and all those clubs had to go back to the robust amateur league with their tails between their legs.

Stay Amateur I say the local pubs have a great trade on friday nights and we all get to play and watch on sunday.
"I walk the line" Johnny Cash the man in black
User avatar
BANYA
Bench Warmer
Bench Warmer
Posts: 635
Joined: Wed May 30, 2007 2:26 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by BANYA »

magicfootball1 wrote:
BANYA wrote:
Ga Pala wrote:Black Brian Didn't you know that players want to play at Clubs like Downs And Gardens for the fantastic environment
And fantastic surrounds not the money? Yeah right :lol:
I do!!! Have you ever spoken to a Downs or Gardens player and asked them why they play there? Most are there because they played Juniors or have family or close friends there. Got naff all to do with $$$. I played 7 years juniors for the Downs, 3 For Salisbury & then 4 years @ SASI. I then played for both Playford & Modbury Seniors (and won a Federation Cup with Playford) and then went to the Downs as a 19yr Old... Why, playing juniors for them helped but because the culture @ Fed Level is non existent, people are plastic and they only like you for what you can do, not who you are. i was so disenchanted by the system that i was ready to give up. Ask yourself why are the two Lindsay boys @ The Downs this yr??? As if they wouldn't walk into a Super League team. Now @ The Downs, where I wouldn't rather spend my weekends playing/supporting anywhere else... My family are welcomed, we are all friends, and now my children are growing up in a fantastic, supportive, family orientated environment. Gay Pala & Bwack Bwian you have no idea, you stick to sipping latte's on the Parade & ill slam back a Pale Ale @ Argy...

uhmmm well funny you should mention Lindsay boys; the fact, they are related to the coach would be the real reason. The fact, the pressure mounted on a lindsay to leave a winning club would be the real reason ? The fact the coach has made a big who-ha about winning this year, you talk so much BS.
The main issue as Bomber puts it, is the big picture whether we play amatuer or fed we all play the same game and should be working together not against each other.

i do agree with you "Why, playing juniors for them helped but because the culture @ Fed Level is non existent, people are plastic and they only like you for what you can do, not who you are"

I talk BS but then you agree with me :roll: Someone should pass the Dutchy to left hand side...
WHY DO THEY CALL IT OVALTINE? I MEAN ITS ROUND, WHY DONT THEY CALL IT ROUNDTINE.
User avatar
KING NUGGETT
Star Player
Star Player
Posts: 2482
Joined: Mon May 17, 2010 2:36 pm

Re: CLUBS GETTING CALLS TO JOIN STATE LEAGUE IN 2013

Post by KING NUGGETT »

I'm sick to death of hearing all this bullsh*t about the FFSA & SAASL...
It all should be about the betterment & growth of Our Game in this State but somehow it's turned into a sh*t fight between both Associations with both being Stuborn & Not Negotiable. WTF ???
All this infighting in our Sport, the "US & THEM MENTALITY" isn't doing the Game any favours at all...

Does anyone actually know what the Real Issues are, & why they cant Negotiate & come to an agreement? I've had brief conversations with the SAASL about it, but I have always come away non the wiser! Something about a $10-$15 FFA Player Fee for every player, something about Insurance the FFSA doesn't like how the SAASL self funded Insurance & something about one administration of the sport....
I'm not entirely sure can anyone shed light on the actual issues stopping unification of our Sport in this State?

The Whole Football Community in this State should Petition to the Government to intervene & get this resolved so Football in this State can move forward....




SAASL DIV.1 CHAMPIONS 73,75,78,02,10,11,13
CHALLENGE CUP WINNERS 74,75,80,08,10,11,13
SAASL DIV.1 RES. CHAMPIONS 71,75,77,78,79,94,11,13
RES. CUP WINNERS 73,75,76,13
CHAMPIONS OF CHAMPIONS 10
CICHANOWSKI SHIELD 90,08,11,12,14

Est.1966
Post Reply